May 16, 2022·2 repliesFair rating.
May 16, 2022Allen IversonFair rating.
- May 16, 2022
Nothing can be perfect all the time
May 16, 2022
Young DPitchfork has always been absolutely WOAT when it comes to reviewing hip hop
But they've just flat out become horrible in general the last 5 years. They've become hyper focused on feeding into some cac-woke agenda that they've lost sight of reviews focused on whether the music is good or not.
May 16, 2022·2 replies
NothingIsit’s pretty self-explanatory tbh
the way he tells the story, it’s like he’s begging the listener to applaud him as a hero for not using a slur anymore (while using that slur to get his point across??)
going from “bad” to “the bare minimum” isn’t applause-worthy
If Kodak wasn’t on the album you wouldn’t even be saying this.
I know you
Nessy 🦎May 16, 2022
rvi"he makes himself the main character in his queer relatives’ stories "
what did they mean by this
That’s so unlike kendrick
May 16, 2022FaithIf Kodak wasn’t on the album you wouldn’t even be saying this.
I know you
LMAO AYE
May 16, 2022·1 reply
A Mad Ass NiggaLet me guess, the mfs that talk down on critics are now d***riding them? I don’t even gotta read the thread. Ktt just go with whatever narrative fit their arguments lol.
and the ones that big up their favs with critic's reception downplaying this score
but like you said whatever fits the narrative
May 16, 2022·1 reply
UNQhttps://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/bad-bunny-un-verano-sin-ti/
Different writer.
This writer has never given anything above a 7 in their reviews.
The writer that reviewed this wouldn't have given bad bunny an 8.
May 16, 2022ain't mad at that score, pretty accurate
- Nessy 🦎May 16, 2022
P4k couldnt keep the lights on at their offices if ktt stopped reading their reviews
- May 16, 2022scurry
and the ones that big up their favs with critic's reception downplaying this score
but like you said whatever fits the narrative
They could be
I only read pages 18 and 19. So I’ll take your word on that. 
May 16, 2022Not reading any of it but that’s a fair score
May 16, 2022·1 replyTakotchiDifferent writer.
This writer has never given anything above a 7 in their reviews.
The writer that reviewed this wouldn't have given bad bunny an 8.
they get the entire staff that listened to the album n average out the score. than pick a reviewer thats closes to the score
- May 16, 2022·1 replyboobdylan
they get the entire staff that listened to the album n average out the score. than pick a reviewer thats closes to the score
Is this real that sounds so unnecessary lol
- May 16, 2022·1 replyTakotchi
Is this real that sounds so unnecessary lol
this is what pitchfork used to do like decade ago. maybe its different now
- May 16, 2022·1 replyboobdylan
this is what pitchfork used to do like decade ago. maybe its different now
yeah no at the height of covid I cant imagine them all in zoom calls listening to the album at the same time lol
- May 16, 2022Takotchi
yeah no at the height of covid I cant imagine them all in zoom calls listening to the album at the same time lol
nah nah i saw screenshots of reviewers giving each other their score for the album on slack
- May 16, 2022NothingIs
it’s pretty self-explanatory tbh
the way he tells the story, it’s like he’s begging the listener to applaud him as a hero for not using a slur anymore (while using that slur to get his point across??)
going from “bad” to “the bare minimum” isn’t applause-worthy
this is such a bad faith, uncharitable way to look at this song lmao
May 16, 2022Great stuff
May 16, 2022·2 repliesAs always f*** P4K… but other reviewers still pay attention to them so expect the average score on meta to drop significantly imo. Could be the start of the critical downfall of Kendrick Lamar
May 16, 2022Halloween GangShould’ve been higher, at least an 8.5. It’s a 9.5 or even a 10 in my book. I’d bet pitchfork bumped it down mainly because of his use of the f-word
Yep.
May 16, 2022Thank you Pitchfork, for providing free therapy to the stans that base their enjoyment of an album over what the critics rate it.
- May 16, 2022
Skrimps N Grits
yeah this definitely looks like the kind of guy that wrote this review
- May 16, 2022·2 repliesAftermathbws_
As always f*** P4K… but other reviewers still pay attention to them so expect the average score on meta to drop significantly imo. Could be the start of the critical downfall of Kendrick Lamar
Nah lol Pitchfork literally the only publication to give it a lower score so far and probably will be the only one. Everyone else I’ve see has been ridiculously high.