Reply
  • Gosh 😹
    Jan 15
    Ā·
    1 reply
    BigSpud

    It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

    At first I disagreed but after reading through this It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

  • Gosh

    At first I disagreed but after reading through this It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

    THANK YOU! Finally someone else with sense.

  • cool beat. song went in one ear and out the other. maybe I’m just waiting for the lucki album now.

  • SABMAN TURNT

    never listened to him tbh, his name sounds like a country artist so i usually avoid songs with him

    Dawg what lol

  • Also Port Antonio was way better than this track. Neither have any commercial appeal but Port Antonio at least had something to say.

    cLOUDs was awful lyrical miracle s*** over an interesting beat.

    Hope Cole has more songs like PA on this.

  • Jan 15
    Mr Carter

    Do we know if Cole produced this?

    original beat was made by maneesh for ye / drake. found it in a whole folder of beats maneesh made for the project. then he brought in Dzl to do the drums and more co prod

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    1 reply
    SABMAN TURNT

    never listened to him tbh, his name sounds like a country artist so i usually avoid songs with him

    Sab delete this bullshit man

  • Valentine 🦦
    Jan 15

    bro typed an essay to me

    The Fall-Off 22 days away! Cole we back nigga, they got opinions

  • Jan 15
    mov

    Song is so f***ing boring

    Lyrical exercise.

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    2 replies

    Cole is technically so impressive man, but something about him just doesn’t hit my soul as it should. I think a part of it is his delivery.

  • Gosh 😹
    Jan 15

    My gut just told me Jordan Ward will be on this

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    4 replies
    ThaDon

    Cole is technically so impressive man, but something about him just doesn’t hit my soul as it should. I think a part of it is his delivery.

    Can you explain why Kendrick hits your soul in a way Cole doesn’t? This question isn’t to stir drama. Very genuine cause I think Kendrick more of a jazz guy Cole more soul Krit more blues

  • BigSpud

    It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

    I actually see where you coming from cus It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

  • Alexandrian

    Can you explain why Kendrick hits your soul in a way Cole doesn’t? This question isn’t to stir drama. Very genuine cause I think Kendrick more of a jazz guy Cole more soul Krit more blues

    All ass

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    1 reply
    Alexandrian

    Can you explain why Kendrick hits your soul in a way Cole doesn’t? This question isn’t to stir drama. Very genuine cause I think Kendrick more of a jazz guy Cole more soul Krit more blues

    Probably cause Kendrick doesn't rap like he's reading from a notebook

  • LickMyBalls

    Probably cause Kendrick doesn't rap like he's reading from a notebook

    Can't read when it's three niggas in one room, first time I was tossed

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    1 reply
    Alexandrian

    Can you explain why Kendrick hits your soul in a way Cole doesn’t? This question isn’t to stir drama. Very genuine cause I think Kendrick more of a jazz guy Cole more soul Krit more blues

    This might be a strange answer but for me its because Cole doesn't seem to have any malice/anger in him.

    I tend to gravitate more towards rappers that will put a bit more of that emotion on the mic and Cole doesn't seem to be capable of that. Kendrick I can feel it through his delivery even on some of the less agressive tracks he releases.

    That being said, I feel like a lot of people do like Cole and find it easier to relate to him specifically because he seems like a chill guy on the mic.

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    1 reply
    Alexandrian

    Can you explain why Kendrick hits your soul in a way Cole doesn’t? This question isn’t to stir drama. Very genuine cause I think Kendrick more of a jazz guy Cole more soul Krit more blues

    No offense taken. Funny you say Krit I loved him back in the day (still do).

    I hope what I’m saying makes sense, but with Cole I feel like he’s talking AT me. With Kendrick I feel like he is talking about his life/topics but not lecturing me. He’s just talking from his perspective. Cole feels more like a lecture.

    There are definitely exceptions, like Neighbors which he obviously killed. But as a general matter this is the difference IMO

  • ThaDon

    No offense taken. Funny you say Krit I loved him back in the day (still do).

    I hope what I’m saying makes sense, but with Cole I feel like he’s talking AT me. With Kendrick I feel like he is talking about his life/topics but not lecturing me. He’s just talking from his perspective. Cole feels more like a lecture.

    There are definitely exceptions, like Neighbors which he obviously killed. But as a general matter this is the difference IMO

    It’s interesting you say this because I think Cole talking at me gives me a soulful connection.

    I think both do lectures and talks at me but I see what you mean.

  • redtruth

    This might be a strange answer but for me its because Cole doesn't seem to have any malice/anger in him.

    I tend to gravitate more towards rappers that will put a bit more of that emotion on the mic and Cole doesn't seem to be capable of that. Kendrick I can feel it through his delivery even on some of the less agressive tracks he releases.

    That being said, I feel like a lot of people do like Cole and find it easier to relate to him specifically because he seems like a chill guy on the mic.

    Fair

  • SABMAN TURNT šŸ§”šŸ»
    Jan 15
    Ā·
    2 replies
    NoFace

    Sab delete this bullshit man

    IM NOT WRONG

    you read the name ā€œKenny Masonā€ with no other context, safe to assume that’s probably a country music star

  • Kendrick just has a much more interesting delivery than Cole. Even on his lyrically dense tracks, he’ll find ways to phrase things or use voice inflections that keep your interest, unlike Cole who seems content to use the same monotone flow and rhyme scheme for an entire track.

    Real is a Kendrick track that I find quite boring for this reason - his verses are dull and the song feels like a slog. Neighbours is a Cole where the flow switches up a lot and it makes for a good listen.

  • Jan 15
    Ā·
    edited
    Ā·
    2 replies
    BigSpud

    It’s not an issue that the concept has been done - how many rap songs have been made using a girl as a metaphor for something else (I Used to Love H.E.R., Homecoming, Gloria, etc.) and it’s still good.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood or whatever, but instead it was literal stuff like ā€œbaby go back in stomachā€ and ā€œI’m growing shorterā€. That is exactly what Nas did on Rewind so it’s not as interesting here.

    It’s also just boring narratively. It’s not interesting to hear about someone who is born, gets married, has kids and dies. The story on Rewind is like a scene from a mafia movie in reverse and has the twist of the shooting at the start of the track being set up at the end.

    Also, Rewind was just a quick throwaway track and more of a fun story than anything. Cole releasing it with a music video to build hype for his album he’s been promoting for half a decade is anticlimactic.

    I know this is overthinking the whole thing but it just really feels like a boring take on the concept and I don’t understand why he chose this as the first track to release. If it was a random song on the album, whatever. But this should be his best foot forward.

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood

    While I see ur point about it being literal, I do think he uses his events in his life to paint the picture of the cycle hes referring to with the concept for the Fall Off, the rise and fall of an artist especially as it pertains to his life

    The inspiration was rare and in spurts, but when it's there, I'm immersed

    Dealing with writer's block as you age as an artist

    With each day that passes, I could feel my career comin' first

    Putting his career before his family

    And though I'm blessed, I see me stressin' from hearin' the chirps
    Of naysayers who, only days later, I don't care to convert

    Dealing with the criticism that comes with being an artist

    Decade later, momma cut on the cable
    My motivation to be greater ends the moment I peer in her purse

    Finding the motivation to be an artist seeing first hand his mom addiction

    I watch my father walk back in my life and it clears up the hurt

    Just a creative way to describe his father leaving and the impact it left on him and his mom

  • J Cole stole his entire gimmick from Dee-1

  • Oblivion X
    Ā· edited

    What I found boring here was that Cole didn’t do anything novel with the concept - it was too literal. When the track started, I thought there’d be some commentary on the changes in his life from fame to coming up to his childhood

    While I see ur point about it being literal, I do think he uses his events in his life to paint the picture of the cycle hes referring to with the concept for the Fall Off, the rise and fall of an artist especially as it pertains to his life

    The inspiration was rare and in spurts, but when it's there, I'm immersed

    Dealing with writer's block as you age as an artist

    With each day that passes, I could feel my career comin' first

    Putting his career before his family

    And though I'm blessed, I see me stressin' from hearin' the chirps
    Of naysayers who, only days later, I don't care to convert

    Dealing with the criticism that comes with being an artist

    Decade later, momma cut on the cable
    My motivation to be greater ends the moment I peer in her purse

    Finding the motivation to be an artist seeing first hand his mom addiction

    I watch my father walk back in my life and it clears up the hurt

    Just a creative way to describe his father leaving and the impact it left on him and his mom