reasonable doubt, blueprint, black album, 444, american gangster are all good-incredible albums
eminem has marshall mathers, SSLP, eminem show and maybe relapse

marshall mathers even tho its good has bad songs and didnt age the best, SSLP also has this problem for some songs, and relapse is deeply flawed to the point i hesitate to put it here its like not even as good as any of the volume series

This is one of the dumbest takes in music history

Eminem has one good album and white rap fans try and re-write him as the greatest artist to have ever lived jesus f***ing christ

wait whats the one album to u he got like 3

no he doesn't

eminem show or whatever it is

SSLP is good and msot of MMLP

agree to disagree

ill take volume 1 over any eminem album post 2002 and thats not even top 5

Nah MMLP his only solid one

All facts

yeah can take that

true

This was a different conversation in the 2000s but at this point, HOV got it from a longevity standpoint since Em has released so much ass in the last decade. Neither of them deserve a spot the in top 5 though.

A Hov verse still means something in 2025

You get an Em verse in 2025 and the reaction is “please don’t ruin the song”

I never would have agreed with this, but 4:44 really showed how wide the gap is between them in their later years.

wait wait 444 means em is better or hov ?

HOV not top 5?

No the f*** he wasn’t

brother off that good kush n alc

4:44 is better than anything Em has dropped since 2003

One of my fav albums oat

Really wish Em would make a mature album like that but he busy trying to rhyme 56 words at 95 mph in a robot voice

I think he wanted Recovery to be that, and MMLP2 has some flashes, but he doesn't know how to be introspective in an accessible, relatable way anymore.

I don‘t mind the complex rhyming when the content & musicality is as good

Its crazy because as technical as he is his lyrics pack no punch now for the most part