Reply
  • Feb 5, 2024
    FOREVA

    is this so called plot progression in the room with us rn?

    can you name anything plot wise that happened between minute 1 and 50?

    😂
    It’s not that slow man
    And the pacing was better this episode than the last few
    All subjective in the end tho!

  • Feb 5, 2024
    RICHAXXVOYCE

    Be patient, the kicker is coming…

  • Feb 5, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    FOREVA

    is this so called plot progression in the room with us rn?

    can you name anything plot wise that happened between minute 1 and 50?

    Figuring out Annie was killed outside of town and brought in, where she was killed in the ice, Tagaq disappearance, everything about Heiss, Julie’s visions taking her to the ice to kill herself - saw same girl Navarro sees at the old crime scene with Danvers, in Julie’s vision wearing the cross Navarro found and threw out of her car last episode -, Danvers’ kid tagging the mine, more exposition re Danvers’ kid and the polar bear recurrence, I could go on —all plot points, you payin attn mate? Pacing is pretty similar to S1 in terms of the slow burn. No major reveals early on, major catalysts are inevitable in the next few episodes. It’s a mystery drama —

  • Feb 5, 2024
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    DEL634

    HBO used to stand for something, now they greenlighting bullshit like this and Tokyo Vice!

    HBO used to stand for something is right though -
    Set the standard for TV and is dead now
    With a few exceptions everything legacy has been axed
    Different team now with different priorities, partnerships for new project curated by previous leadership are dead. It’s a WB entity now top to bottom
    TD is an og survivor

    Also RIP South Side

  • Feb 5, 2024
    awawh

    Figuring out Annie was killed outside of town and brought in, where she was killed in the ice, Tagaq disappearance, everything about Heiss, Julie’s visions taking her to the ice to kill herself - saw same girl Navarro sees at the old crime scene with Danvers, in Julie’s vision wearing the cross Navarro found and threw out of her car last episode -, Danvers’ kid tagging the mine, more exposition re Danvers’ kid and the polar bear recurrence, I could go on —all plot points, you payin attn mate? Pacing is pretty similar to S1 in terms of the slow burn. No major reveals early on, major catalysts are inevitable in the next few episodes. It’s a mystery drama —

    you know what, you’re actually right. the plot progression was a lot better than the last few weeks, BUT

    it still says a lot about it’s direction and narrating style when most people do not notice this at all

    it’s like someone said in here a few pages ago, it just doesn’t stick if all of your characters are bland and show no personality except getting mad or simply being an a****** for the f*** of it

    imo that’s the big difference between this season and the other ones. people used to have philosophies they based their decisions on. we just do not get that in here. they‘re mostly doing s*** just to do it. no solid reasoning or anything behind it

    idk, maybe i shouldn’t have rewatched S1 before finishing this, but this whole season just seems pretentious and dead to me

  • Feb 5, 2024
    ·
    2 replies
    innuendo

    S2-3 deniers you didn't know how good you had it!

    I became an S2 guy bc I rewatched it leading up to this. there's a LOT wrong with it but I can see what they were going for and it's a really cool departure from S1

    I bet if HBO had given Pizza at least another year to flesh it out it could've been amazing

  • Feb 5, 2024
    CRACKASTEPPAVEGAN

    That Mare show was boring af. Stopped at episode 2. Back to your point, I always thought Pizza and Cary Fukunaga helped each other or needed each other to bring results.

    I agree up to a point. I quite enjoyed both season 2 and especially 3. But then again neither are season 1 level. Weird situation all around. Might be karma.

  • Also I can't believe they had the balls to show the Ice Caves so early in the intros. I noticed it way before it became a plot point and it'd be like showing glimpses of Carcosa before S1 finale

  • Feb 6, 2024
  • Feb 6, 2024

    So we’re cool with there just deadass being some people that can see these walking dead spirits huh

  • Feb 6, 2024
    ·
    3 replies

    HBO forced the True Detective branding to an original show, damn

    One thing López didn't want to be compared to, at least at first, was to the first three seasons of True Detective. But, that's because when she envisioned the project originally, it had nothing to do with the show. López says she initially pitched an idea for a project called Night Country, which she describes as "a murder mystery in the ice," and it was HBO who suggested it could be True Detective instead — an idea she says never even crossed her mind. Once the two parties agreed, Night Country became True Detective: Night Country, and López had the unenviable task of "recalling what connected so powerfully with so many people around the world, but at the same time, doing it in your own voice and making it your own."

    forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2024/01/23/this-is-why-true-detective-night-countrys-season-1-connections-feel-so-forced-and-lame

  • Feb 6, 2024
    innuendo




    thinking of going back to this first two episodes weren’t doing it for me the last time I tried

    might get better for me the way that the Wire season 2 has

  • Feb 6, 2024
    awawh

    HBO used to stand for something is right though -
    Set the standard for TV and is dead now
    With a few exceptions everything legacy has been axed
    Different team now with different priorities, partnerships for new project curated by previous leadership are dead. It’s a WB entity now top to bottom
    TD is an og survivor

    Also RIP South Side

    cancelling Winning Time was the dumbest s*** they’ve done recently

  • Feb 6, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    these reactions itt are interesting, I stopped after the first couple episodes but the viewings/ratings are popping with audiences

    is this show popular with people irl at all, i honestly can’t tell

  • Feb 6, 2024
    innuendo

    S2-3 deniers you didn't know how good you had it!

  • Feb 6, 2024
    innuendo

    S2-3 deniers you didn't know how good you had it!

    don’t try & group them together

  • Feb 6, 2024
    DEL634

    Come on, man. You can't stop now. Sit it out with the rest of us..

    Oh Danny my boy 😔 it’s over

  • Feb 6, 2024

    Bro I'm glad they stopped it, if I had to watch old people f*** I was throwing my OLED off the balcony.

  • Feb 6, 2024
    Antidote

    HBO forced the True Detective branding to an original show, damn

    One thing López didn't want to be compared to, at least at first, was to the first three seasons of True Detective. But, that's because when she envisioned the project originally, it had nothing to do with the show. López says she initially pitched an idea for a project called Night Country, which she describes as "a murder mystery in the ice," and it was HBO who suggested it could be True Detective instead — an idea she says never even crossed her mind. Once the two parties agreed, Night Country became True Detective: Night Country, and López had the unenviable task of "recalling what connected so powerfully with so many people around the world, but at the same time, doing it in your own voice and making it your own."

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2024/01/23/this-is-why-true-detective-night-countrys-season-1-connections-feel-so-forced-and-lame/

    Makes a lot of sense tbh

  • Feb 6, 2024
    SIGH

    Does Jodie really hate Twist and Shout because that one guy whistled it out of tune for a few seconds

    It's likely because that's what was playing during some weird drunken driving incident that killed her child and maybe husband.

    That's the vibes that I'm getting at least. It feels obvious without saying it.

  • Feb 6, 2024
    ·
    1 reply
    _jesse

    What’s the consensus on s4? Started ep 1 and it seems promising. I enjoyed the showrunner’s past work

    It's not bad, but it doesn't hit the highs of season 1.
    There's not enough engaging material here for me to be really interested. I never watched season 2 and I was meh in 3 but this season isn't bad. I would say wait a week and binge all 6 episodes.

  • Feb 6, 2024
    Bo Ceephus

    It's not bad, but it doesn't hit the highs of season 1.
    There's not enough engaging material here for me to be really interested. I never watched season 2 and I was meh in 3 but this season isn't bad. I would say wait a week and binge all 6 episodes.

    Might do just that

    Havent seen s1 since it released gonna go back and rewatch

  • Feb 6, 2024
    ·
    1 reply

    I know I’m talking too much about not liking this show but this has me crying

  • Feb 6, 2024
    FOREVA

    is this so called plot progression in the room with us rn?

    can you name anything plot wise that happened between minute 1 and 50?

    Like the dude before me said, from the ice caves and Otto Heiss to the dredge, etc., there was definitely significant movement on the case progression

  • Feb 6, 2024

    But yeah, in general, they should've just made this a 4 episode miniseries to cut out the extra fat and create more dynamic plot movement, make it not related to TD, cut out the forced references to S1. & it probably would've been a lot better received.

    & the irony is, if they would've done that, I bet 90% of twitter or reddit would've been like "This is what True detective should be like again"

1
...
35
36
37
...
61