There's no disproportionate dominance because there's just not a lot of trans athletes. A lot of the ones who did transition and then went to women's sports went from mediocre or solid men's records into upper tier women records. One of then was juniper Eastwood who said her pre transition records in high school would have made her a national champ for women divisions.
There is undoubtedly a massive physical advantage, even after HRT.

I never denied that there was an advantage, it's just not bigger than other advantages we don't have any issue with

Trans women after HRT are a lot closer to cis women in terms of strength than cis men

There's no disproportionate dominance because there's just not a lot of trans athletes.

Do you know what disproportionate means

Idk if they are. Because if that’s the case then why are trans men not close to cis men?

Women’s sports only exists bc women didn’t/couldn’t compete with men

Not bc men banned women from competing with them

So the entire advantage/disadvantage thing doesn’t make sense bc there are only 2 leagues:

Everybody league

Biologically female league

I don’t get why a league made for a specific group/type of people should have to change their standards to let in people that they did not design the league for. Other than bc it would hurt ppls feelings
If you don’t fit in the 2nd league compete in the first league

They actually are closer

The disadvantage of trans men is also smaller than the advantage of trans women btw

Yeah why would trans people care about being misgendered to the point of competing in the wrong category if sports is so important to them lol

It’s not misgender it’s accurate born s**

You do know that women are not banned from the NBA

Personal life =/= sports

Every one has to make sacrifices

Then why do trans women over compete and trans men under compete compared to what they did pre transition?

I know what all the studies and s*** say should be happening in theory but in practice things are going down the opposite way

Being trans isn't a personal life choice so this doesn't mean anything

If you are one standard deviation above the male mean for a physically advantageous trait, you are several standard deviations above the female mean. This is problematic because these traits are presumably distributed roughly normally and not uniformly, so each standard deviation makes you "rarer".

Your argument seems to be "Well, LeBron is massive and insanely quick and explosive, so why didn't we ban him from the NBA?". The difference is that LeBron is still within the bounds of conceivable male athletes, he's just on the very far side of spectrum.

If LeBron decided to transition into a woman, she would be a god with a literal one-in-a-trillion combination of size and athleticism relative to her competitors, and would drop 300 points a game.

The decision to take hormones or have any types of surgery is completely a personal choice

I'm not saying that they don't, just not as much as people are saying, it's easy to portray that narrative using anecdotes and not actual statistics.

Again my point is not that the advantage/disadvantage doesn't exist, it's just that the advantage isn't as big as other advantages that we don't make the same big deal out of.

Would u say getting treated for cancer is a personal life choice?

If I had cancer and decided to go to chemo instead of my soccer game, yes it is my personal choice

I can’t make demands that they change the date of the game for me or change rules for me/my personal life choices

this is borderline unhinged

This reply let’s me know that you know it is a personal choice

And it’s funny you brought up cancer bc I went to high school with someone who had to stop playing soccer bc of it (which was why I brought up soccer)

Which is also why my original point was that everyone has to make sacrifices

Scratchin Bandit only knows how to argue via false equivalences unfortunately

quite obviously yes, is english your second language?

He's making a fair argument about the difference between the genetic advantage of maleness and other genetic advantages.

I don't completely agree with him, but I think his point is important to discuss.

Cause nobody watches swimming like that.