Reply
  • RASIE 🎣
    May 22, 2020
    rvi

    body talk deserved higher rank

    honey almost as good too imo

    "Call Your Girlfriend" wouldve made my singles list for sure too

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    5 replies

    Some snubs imo on top of my head:
    no love for Lemonade
    The National got 2 albums in but nothing from The War On D**** or Beck.
    Was Abel snubbed too?
    Jon Hopkins’ Immunity snubbed
    Disclosure’s Settle snubbed
    Slowdive’s Self Titled
    Perfume Genius
    Moses
    I didn’t see Melodrama either
    No James Blake
    The xx (although Jamie solo made it, but that was low as f***)
    Arctic Monkeys
    St Vincent
    Maxwell
    Kelela
    Angel Olsen

  • May 22, 2020

    MBDTF, Yeezus and Blonde

    My top 3 won

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply

    i agree that the brand of poptimism thats like "actually phil collins was good" is dumb. but for like 50 years the vast majority of music criticism was done by, for and about white men and certain artists were canonized accordingly. an overcorrection is due and using "ree poptimism" to criticize women who make dope music is dumb.

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Koala

    Dr J forgot to add it but its still

    I didn’t forget

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    2 replies
    UIP

    much better than EMOTION and i’m a huge Carly fan lol

    but you put EMOTION at 11 and Body Talk at 41 so explain this to me chief.

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    2 replies

    how do threads like this never appear until voting is over

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    psychedelic

    Some snubs imo on top of my head:
    no love for Lemonade
    The National got 2 albums in but nothing from The War On D**** or Beck.
    Was Abel snubbed too?
    Jon Hopkins’ Immunity snubbed
    Disclosure’s Settle snubbed
    Slowdive’s Self Titled
    Perfume Genius
    Moses
    I didn’t see Melodrama either
    No James Blake
    The xx (although Jamie solo made it, but that was low as f***)
    Arctic Monkeys
    St Vincent
    Maxwell
    Kelela
    Angel Olsen

    theres a list in op of albums didnt make the cut. like half the artists u listed did make the top 100 tho lol

  • May 22, 2020
    suzuki

    theres a list in op of albums didnt make the cut. like half the artists u listed did make the top 100 tho lol

    Oh I’ll check it out

  • May 22, 2020

    thanks for making this, a fun read. early and danny brown won

  • May 22, 2020
    psychedelic

    Some snubs imo on top of my head:
    no love for Lemonade
    The National got 2 albums in but nothing from The War On D**** or Beck.
    Was Abel snubbed too?
    Jon Hopkins’ Immunity snubbed
    Disclosure’s Settle snubbed
    Slowdive’s Self Titled
    Perfume Genius
    Moses
    I didn’t see Melodrama either
    No James Blake
    The xx (although Jamie solo made it, but that was low as f***)
    Arctic Monkeys
    St Vincent
    Maxwell
    Kelela
    Angel Olsen

    Click on the link in OP to contrast lists

  • May 22, 2020
    RASIE

    That's true, and Im sure the rise of the internet factors into that a decent bit as well too

    Also, remember when Robyn dropped Body Talk five years before the "once in a generation album" Emotion?

    !https://youtu.be/F6ImxY6hnfA!https://youtu.be/ueI8HU1cmNE

    true, which makes the hype for Carly just weirder to me.

    Then again, I like a few Carly songs.

    I guess reading through the reviews and looking at what happened sociopolitcally at the time would help but I have literally zero idea.

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Slingshot

    how do threads like this never appear until voting is over

    Real ones knew where voting was
    Not too late to send me your list of fav movies from last decade though

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    psychedelic

    Some snubs imo on top of my head:
    no love for Lemonade
    The National got 2 albums in but nothing from The War On D**** or Beck.
    Was Abel snubbed too?
    Jon Hopkins’ Immunity snubbed
    Disclosure’s Settle snubbed
    Slowdive’s Self Titled
    Perfume Genius
    Moses
    I didn’t see Melodrama either
    No James Blake
    The xx (although Jamie solo made it, but that was low as f***)
    Arctic Monkeys
    St Vincent
    Maxwell
    Kelela
    Angel Olsen

    House of Balloons is in the 50 range
    James Blake self titled is in the 50 range

    I agree about St Vincent

    Beyonce got 0 votes but that still seems like too many.

    The rest is up for debate onwhether they should be included but this list is more of a representation of our Fam thread (exceot for TPAB at 10 get that s*** outta here) and not trying to cater to any audience.

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    2 replies

    i agree that lil b is influential and it was really fun at the time but if u still bumping wonton soup and doing the cooking dance u need help frfr

  • May 22, 2020
    drjdeponytail

    I didn’t forget

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    laudi

    Real ones knew where voting was
    Not too late to send me your list of fav movies from last decade though

    movies? betttt where at

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Galaxy

    House of Balloons is in the 50 range
    James Blake self titled is in the 50 range

    I agree about St Vincent

    Beyonce got 0 votes but that still seems like too many.

    The rest is up for debate onwhether they should be included but this list is more of a representation of our Fam thread (exceot for TPAB at 10 get that s*** outta here) and not trying to cater to any audience.

    Salty ass post

  • rvi 🦜
    May 22, 2020
    Galaxy

    but you put EMOTION at 11 and Body Talk at 41 so explain this to me chief.

    got him

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    Slingshot

    movies? betttt where at

    @ meh in MSCT when you’re done

  • May 22, 2020
    Slingshot

    how do threads like this never appear until voting is over

    did you read OP? This was a private voting process with people of a specific thread to see what our list would look like. didnt want to havbe any outside influence. Sorry for the exclusion but this was a list for the indie FAM!

  • May 22, 2020
    laudi

    @ meh in MSCT when you’re done

    no specific number? gotu

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    1 reply
    suzuki

    i agree that lil b is influential and it was really fun at the time but if u still bumping wonton soup and doing the cooking dance u need help frfr

  • May 22, 2020
    laudi

    Salty ass post

    just banter

  • May 22, 2020
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies

    Emotion didn't even get rave reviews. It was mostly 7/10s across the board

    And up until its release, she was merely a one-hit wonder whose mainstream career was assumed to be all but dead.

    It's debatable if it was even the best pop album of the decade but it's undeniable that it was the most influential pop album of the decade when it came to the genre's consumption.

    It's not that deep

1
...
11
12
13
...
21