redios

1d

not sure about better music but i like his topic more than Em's (which doesn't say much because i don't care for either of their topics)

whitegirl

1d

· edited

Jayz clearly makes better music his production is literally top 3 OAT

I definitely relate mor me to eminems lyrics tho

shaleirose

1d

How is anything I'm saying a fallacy?

1. Popularity has no bearings on quality when it comes to art

2. Eminem's status in contemporary rap wouldn't be different if he dropped more albums throughout his prime, because the problem for people wasn't the quantity, it was the quality of everything after The Eminem Show

Aisosa

1d

Jay Z makes accessible music

whitegirl

1d

This thread hella nerdy why are we discussing new york times

whitegirl

1d

Jayz clearly makes better music his production is literally top 3 OAT

I definitely relate mor me to eminems lyrics tho

whitegirl

1d

Eminem is literally hip hop linkin park

Which means hes a goat

whitegirl

1d

Eminem is literally hip hop linkin park

Which means hes a goat

Aisosa

1d

No, you dunce.

There's no such thing as good or bad music, only music you like or dislike.

I would rather die than listen to a Kate Busb album but some niggas think that s*** is the best thing on the planet

redios

1d

true but i don't really credit him much for it. He had Kanye producing for him. thats a cheat code right there. Em had goat production too when he had access to prime Dre beats. The only goat that doesn't have top tier production is Nas

SyIIabIes

1d

If he dropped in his prime like Jay did it wouldn’t have been ass compared to his newer stuff
Jay dropped 8 albums compared (collab albums included) to ems 4 albums
Re-Up wasn’t a collab album just a compilation

shaleirose

1d

See, this is why I said having this discussion with you is pointless.

We were discussing the quality of Eminem’s recent music, and you tried to disqualify me calling it garbage by saying that “millions of people disagree”. So clearly, you view quality as something objective that can be measured by commercial performance, but that’s just not the case at all

Aisosa

1d

No, I view quality as subjective.

I LITERALLY JUST SAID THAT.

Can you read, my guy?

whitegirl

1d

90s nas had amazing production tho

Jayz has longevity but at their peaks nas rivals jayz musically

shaleirose

1d

Okay, so then why say “millions of people disagree”

Who gives a s*** what millions of people think? The masses eat up bullshit all the time in numerous mediums of art

The Transformers movies made bank

Call of Duty makes bank every year

There’s always bullshit at the top of the music charts

Mark Moschino

1d

@op by this logic hemingway sucks because he writes in mechanical speak

shaleirose

1d

Eminem was past his creative prime when Encore dropped pretty much

He dropped almost every year from 1999-2002

Aisosa

2d

Do you think Jay Z is a better songwriter than Eminem?

Aisosa

1d

Eminem would actually be Hemingway in this a***ogy

Mark Moschino

1d

in what f***ing universe?