Reply
  • ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    The point is there is nothing anyone can say to convince you that Jay is the better writer, your mind is made up already

    You could discuss the actual lyrics?

    You don't seem to have this much trouble debating against Drake fans who have their minds made up in the sales thread

  • ·
    2 replies
    shaleirose

    The Black Album
    American Gangster
    Watch the Throne
    4:44

    All released after 2002

    All horrendous albums (see what I did there?)

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    You could discuss the actual lyrics?

    You don't seem to have this much trouble debating against Drake fans who have their minds made up in the sales thread

    Because sales are not subjective

    Taste and preference is

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    All horrendous albums (see what I did there?)

    I don't believe you know more than 10 songs collectively on those 4 albums combined

  • ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    Because sales are not subjective

    Taste and preference is

    I saw you argue with Drake stans for 10 pages over the allegedly objective GNX sales.

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    I saw you argue with Drake stans for 10 pages over the allegedly objective GNX sales.

    They weren't allegedly objective, they are objective

  • ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I don't believe you know more than 10 songs collectively on those 4 albums combined

    I've probably listened to more Jay Z (and hip hop in general) than you have.

  • ·
    2 replies
    shaleirose

    They weren't allegedly objective, they are objective

    So why could anybody argue that GNX wasn't the biggest album of the decade?

  • ·
    3 replies
    Aisosa

    I've probably listened to more Jay Z (and hip hop in general) than you have.

    I'm pressing X on that one

  • ·
    1 reply
    redios

    Like I said, jay’s legacy is based on myth and falls apart like a house of cards upon any examination. He supposed has this discog full of classics that no listens to anymore. He’s also this great song writer but can’t make a hit without features to save his life. Literal sand castle legacy

    Vol 1-2 still hold up
    BP1 is classic hands down
    BP2 bloated but has some joints but a few songs on here are weak sure
    Black Album classic hands down
    KC mid to decent at best
    AG classic but i rarely run it back
    BP3 classic and Jay’s take on a blog era style album lol
    WTT classic

    Everything here I either bump regularly or consistently run back songs from even the weaker/lesser played joints here (Ignorant S***, The Prelude, Hovi Baby)

  • Aisosa

    So why could anybody argue that GNX wasn't the biggest album of the decade?

    Because they're people who deny reality based on their obsession with one man

  • ·
    2 replies
    shaleirose

    Remove 1999-2002 and Eminem has one of the worst discographies of all-time in rap music

    Encore
    Relapse (Dre did his part tho)
    Recovery
    MMLP2
    Revival
    Kamikaze
    MTBMB
    MTBMB - Side B
    Death of Slim Shady

    What other hip hop artist has this many bombs?

  • notbrock

    Encore
    Relapse (Dre did his part tho)
    Recovery
    MMLP2
    Revival
    Kamikaze
    MTBMB
    MTBMB - Side B
    Death of Slim Shady

    What other hip hop artist has this many bombs?

    Like it's really wild to see it written out like that

  • Aisosa

    All horrendous albums (see what I did there?)

    Uh lied?

  • ·
    1 reply
    shaleirose

    I'm pressing X on that one

    What's your favorite Yung Joc album?

  • Mans begging for attention

  • shaleirose

    I'm pressing X on that one

    What was the first hip hop album you bought?

  • Op flurkin

  • shaleirose

    I'm pressing X on that one

    Why is Vince Staples a better rapper than Earl Sweatshirt?

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    So why could anybody argue that GNX wasn't the biggest album of the decade?

    One listen classic

  • whitegirl

    One listen classic

    shalirose gon murk you in your sleep

  • ·
    1 reply
    redios

    Like I said, jay’s legacy is based on myth and falls apart like a house of cards upon any examination. He supposed has this discog full of classics that no listens to anymore. He’s also this great song writer but can’t make a hit without features to save his life. Literal sand castle legacy

    He supposed has this discog full of classics that no listens to anymore.

    This is not true whatsoever. Besides Eminem, he is the only rapper that debuted before the 21st Century that's currently in the Top 100 on Spotify. The next closest are 2Pac at #191 and Biggie at #280.

    He's also this great songwriter but can't make a hit without features to save his life

    Also, not true. Jay is one of 21 artists ever to amass at least 100 entries on the Hot 100. For rappers, he's one of 12. Regardless, being a great songwriter is not about making hits, it's about writing poignant songs

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    What's your favorite Yung Joc album?

    Is Yung Joc the barometer for being a hip-hop fan?

  • shaleirose

    Remove 1999-2002 and Eminem has one of the worst discographies of all-time in rap music

    True

  • ·
    1 reply
    Aisosa

    Could say the same for Jay Z

    False

1
...
11
12
13
...
22