Reply
  • Mar 22, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    Ye is alright. People on the internet talk in extremes. Its either a classic or trash. Ye has like 3 great songs (Ghost Town, ITAKY, Violent Crimes). The other songs on there are just ok. If you make a 7 songs album, every song needs to be a banger

  • Mar 22, 2025

    for me yes, but on ktt2 it's a big divide
    ghost town and violent crimes are 2 of the best songs he's made in a decade

  • Mar 22, 2025

    Mid. I only go back to Ghost Town and Violent Crimes (which has aged like milk)

  • Mar 22, 2025
    aaron xx


    given the current circumstances, would you say this album has aged well? i think this album marked a change in ye's attitude and is personally in my top 3 kanye albums

    Only if you compare it to the non donda .material that followed. On its own it's extremely unremarkable

    Makes sense that it was just thrown together last minute to replace the MAGA album

  • Mar 22, 2025

    It was ass when it dropped, it's ass now.

  • Mar 22, 2025
    im ticklish giggle

    never listened to it

    real

  • Mar 22, 2025
    ·
    1 reply


    trash album

  • Mar 22, 2025
    mov

    Very good album for me personally and I don't care about other opinions

    Of course it's not top 5 in his discog but who cares

    you get it

  • rx friendly ghost


    trash album

    it has aged worse than this and at least this has good times

  • Mar 22, 2025
    Shin Chan

    Bad album. Still bad.

  • Mar 22, 2025

    Great album. And like others here said not everything has to be compared to other projects or fit into album rankings. The album can stand on its own and has no bad song it.

  • Na its best we forget about this attempt at a drake album

  • if we're being honest absolutely not

    his mental health spiraled further and the love songs are about kim not leaving him

    also the music is mostly ass

  • Mar 22, 2025
    Abyss

    Ye is alright. People on the internet talk in extremes. Its either a classic or trash. Ye has like 3 great songs (Ghost Town, ITAKY, Violent Crimes). The other songs on there are just ok. If you make a 7 songs album, every song needs to be a banger

    Daytona did great with 7 songs but I feel like the Ye albums never got a chance to breathe or really take off being confined to 7 tracks

  • Mar 22, 2025

    Bro didn’t put the title cause he knows I wouldn’t have joined the thread otherwise

    I hate you!

  • No