notbrock

2y

Being a good rapper doesn’t mean your a lyrical miracle ass rapper

Idk what the f*** is so hard to understand about that

shaleirose

2y

Carti CAN rap though.

Rap is about much more than just lyricism.

When it comes to cadence, delivery, and flow he’s in a league of his own

shaleirose

2y

And not being a lyrically heavy rapper doesn’t mean you’re a bad rapper

Idk what’s so hard to understand about that

notbrock

2y

That’s literally what I said

shaleirose

2y

I can post whatever, you’ll write it off because it’s not lyrical

If you actually listened to Carti you would understand

notbrock

2y

I do listen to Carti. Die Lit was one of my most listened to albums of 2018

Y’all acting like you have this deeper understanding or some s***

And I don’t care if it’s “lyrical”

Rocky ain’t lyrical at all but can still rap good as f***

shaleirose

2y

Okay so then you shouldn’t be questioning why people gravitate towards Carti and enjoy his music and why he receives the credit that he does

notbrock

2y

I do think he deserves credit

But people take the s*** annoyingly far. Like yeah he’s cool but f***ing chill lmao

Like some of y’all act like he’s your boyfriend if someone says even the smallest bit of criticism

yungkulfii

2y

Spinning magnolia for the first time walking out of class freshman year was a moment I'll never forget

Free YoungBoy

2y

I don’t understand this because nobody is insulting you, calling you out of your name or taking it away from music. They’re just disagreeing with you. If anyone sensitive it’s you rn lol

notbrock

2y

I mean we’re on a music forum where we discuss music but can’t with Carti because his Stan’s act delusional

Earlier itt I said Cartis producers need more credit because they a big part of his sound and the one dude literally said no they don’t it’s all Carti because his clones don’t have the impact he does even with the same beats

Like that’s just some straight up goofy s*** to say

Free YoungBoy

2y

Ok first of all that was me and you’re misrepresenting what I said because I never said it was all Carti or that his producers didn’t deserve credit.

And second, how can we not discuss music? That’s literally what we’ve all been doing all thread?

Unless you’re the type of nigga that thinks discussion = you say your piece and everyone agrees

notbrock

2y

I just don’t understand why Carti fans can’t acknowledge a single fault in anything he does. I have plenty of criticism against all my favorites

If you can’t see the overly insane d*** riding Carti gets idk what to tell you

Free YoungBoy

2y

I see Carti fans call him out all the time for being a bad person, beating his girl, and s*** like that.

What it really sounds like is you just don’t like his music as much as others here. Which is fine but don’t try and act like everyone else is sensitive when we’re just talking music just like you

notbrock

2y

That’s true I definitely don’t but I’m saying it’s getting annoying

It’s like talking to Eminem Stan’s about hip hop. They make these bold ass claims and give him all this credit when in reality they have no idea what they’re talking about because they aren’t actually hip hop fans, Just em fans. Would you agree with that?

foregone

2y

Sorry where am I being obtuse? I’ve only mentioned race because you said white girls buying your album doesn’t mean you’re running the game. I’m saying that white boys buying your s*** is the same as your argument. It doesn’t mean he’s running the game at all. His influence on this generation is undeniable, but to say he’s running the game cuz he's mad popular with kids under 23 is a stretch

shaleirose

2y

You hear songs like FlatBed Freestyle, @ MEH, Stop Breathing, 2024, & Backr00ms and come to the conclusion that the producers are doing all of the work? What other rapper has showcased such a level of vocal agility as Carti has?

shaleirose

2y

You hear songs like FlatBed Freestyle, @ MEH, Stop Breathing, 2024, & Backr00ms and come to the conclusion that the producers are doing all of the work? What other rapper has showcased such a level of vocal agility as Carti has?

Free YoungBoy

2y

If you’re not a lyrical miracle ass rapper they say you’re carried by production. It’s such a lazy critique

Nightcrawlers

2y

Production wise Travis s***s on Carti and they're both not lyrical really

notbrock

2y

The thing that annoys me with Carti is how much credit he gets for so little effort

The producers should get more credit. Like I understand he’s the one that chose to work with them but it’s not like he’s the first. People were working with Pierre and F1lthy before Carti

Then I feel like his actual contributions are so little. It’s not like he’s saying anything interesting or writing anything clever or funny (Carti Stan’s will try and argue against this but refuse to provide a single example)

And I honestly don’t even hate his music but his fans are like people that only listen to Eminem, S*** just completely puts me off of him

Free YoungBoy

2y

Nah I don’t agree with the Eminem
fan comparison. Especially if we’re talking ktt2 Carti fans.

If anything it’s the niggas that try and write him off as being carried by production or aesthetics that are less knowledgeable/open minded.

Andre Jaquet

2y

nobody cares that you don't like the music bro get out of here ur opinion is not something anyone needs to cosign we all disagree with you this convo ended years ago the voice is an instrument thing should be common sense by now aint no way ur still on the old criteria of what makes a good rapper
this thread isnt even about our personal affinity with his projects