He’s not black

anytime a man is seen in a bent role, can't be good

Show me one accredited review that says that or genuine personal critique;
he has been widely acclaimed by all groups
And I know of many other black authors and economists that look to his opinions in relation to contrast for historical perspective.

You’re making a straw man argument.

why is he here

got him bad

complicated lol.

also just pushing the conversation away from corporate products that influence bad behaviors or outlook.

need people mentally healthy.

actually i have one right here that’s doing a good job

jstor.org/stable/20064098

Stop hiding behind debate tactics to deflect from the discussion

If you were being genuine and intellectually curious you can research the academic critics of his work yourself

I assume you can use Google scholar or your schools library database to access

Also what I made wasn’t even an arguement let alone a straw man

If you aren’t black, then don’t post itt you weirdo

Right but this also is a reply to the post below you;

I have read that, it’s published from 2005 and it’s for the African History / Studies Journal.

The basis of having a critique is valid, but you can find any number of people who will critique anything also purely on the basis
Of dissociation of generalized assertions on “racial experience”.

At that point you are just looking for differing opinions to prove your point, not the accumulated value of criticism .

In a touchy subject, he is over whelming agreed with cross race.

He/She completely misused the most basic logical fallacy

How so?

This is again a vague assertion.

In on 100

Give me your definition of straw man since you called it out

See how this muddies the waters?

okay bro i gave you a chance bc you used some big words but at this point and after having several ppl itt confirm it

you have no argument. please get out the thread. you have no interest in having a good faith argument about black empowerment, and you are obviously here to debate.

i mean you’re literally dismissing anna case mic journal released at the time of the release of this work you cite as invaluable criticism. i’m assuming bc it’s a black studies journal?

there’s nothing you are trying to debate and you’re embarrassing yourself. please find better things to do then harass black people online, it’s
not the best look.

Creating an argument that someone doesn’t know something purely based on an example or statement that only encapsulates on you’re saying within that statement
To seem true within its function

“Example : you wear blue shoes because your avi is blue, and because you wear blue shoes you must be a nazi”

Those types of arguments are not based in reality, but the proposition it’s true based on personally pre set conditionals.

No, and your assumption is also; racist.

I’m refuting it because of the nature of the criticism, based on its criticism

Not it’s place or origin;

In addition to its comparison to all other criticisms.

It’s these conversations that make me wonder if people are on the internet trying to speak “for black people” as “black people” to mislead others
About basic ways to save themselves
Or mostly any one easily influenced
From the world.

I did not make an argument.

I said I doubted your ability to be critical of Sowell’s work because it’s common knowledge amongst modern economists that the claims he makes his book are sus and his actual research output is very little.

If you want to say the argument is the latter part concerning the significant amount of academics being critical of him then prove to me this is false

Why are y’all letting this alt (whose not even black LMFAO) tell you about the black experience in America

But that IS an argument, and it’s a flawed strawman arguemnt because you cant provide
Any more than singular resources,
In relation to overwhelming praise.

It’s like if there were 99 green fish in a bucket, and one red, and after pulling out the red you claimed there must be more fish
No matter what anyone told you.

You’re stinking up the thread man please get out

I’m not an alt, and your assumption that I’m not black is because you feel like I’m not “like you”
Or don’t “think like you”

Which is a racist, corporate mindset in America.