Who is a better writer Taylor swift or Caroline polachek

Page 3 of 3
Reply
  • Mar 15, 2024
    Reply
    TheInstigator

    easily

    dead

  • Mar 15, 2024
    Reply
    EchiTwigs

    Tortured Poet Department so so soon!

  • Mar 16, 2024
    Reply
    Botney

    I know but I dumbed down my argument for people to get it. Who would be a good comparison? Certainly not Madonna.

    Shania Twain! I think that's pretty fair.

  • Joni Mitchell >>>> both

  • Aug 29, 2025
    Reply

    i love both

    not sure

    prob caroline but the way she writes is more vocal based / freestyle top lining then she fills it in with words.

    for some reason, i think taylor is a better lyricist

    can caroline write all too well 10 min version?!?!

  • Aug 29, 2025
    Reply
    KillaSet

    I’m a Caroline Stan but based on strictly writing, Taylor is better, though Caroline’s writing is far more abstract.

    how i feel tbh

1
2
3