Damn I would go by the games I've played the most or influenced my taste the most

Virtua Fighter 2 (I like 5 overall more tho)
Resident Evil 4
SSB Melee (Ultimate overall better as well)

Tony Hawk Underground 2
Tetris
Binding of Isaac

metal gear solid 3
fallout new vegas
red dead redemption

Tetris
Darks souls 1
Xenogears

I missed out on the MGS wave

Real for NV

deus ex
fallout nv
mgs1

Dishonored 2
Mass Effect 1
Witcher 3

HM: Alan Wake

just buy the master collection, man.

Vagrant story fr that good? Been meaning to emulate it and xenogears for a while now

Maybe one day. Currently playing Black Mesa for the first time haven't played HL1 in a couple decades

Xenogears

Melee is better

The atmosphere stuck with me more than any other game. I like how gritty and unique the art style is and the story is amazing too. Music is insane too. Its just the perfect game in my eyes

Baldurs gate 3
Twilight princess
GTA 4 with dlc

Vro that’s like 17 games

That’s high praise definitely gonna peep

bloodborne
yoshis island
mgs2

only top three is hard af

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Elden Ring

Metal Gear Solid
Witcher 3
Half Life 2

Knights of the Old Republic
The Witcher 3
Cyberpunk 2077

Idk I haven’t played Melee in over 10 years. I can see it being better tbh but the cast in Ultimate is so crazy

Witcher 3

Red Dead 2

Mass Effect 2/Mario 64/botw/gta 6

I havent decided on the 3rd one clearly.