We back??

this feels like somebody’s memory of a show & it’s fading away

Pass

I was just doing a szn 1 rewatch and it would be cool to do a prequel about sam Tuttle and billy Childress and the generation that came before Errol (maybe it would occur when Errol was a child). so much good backstory to explore

now u can't have some true detectives going after them only to fail (obviously they didn't solve the full scope of things) but maybe there's 1 bad guy they catch

as for bringing back mcpconaughey and Harrelson in a sequel, that could be fine too if he writes it well. I trust mcconaughey and Harrelson would only do it if its a good script, not just some s***ty sequel

i love sxn 1 so much but this is pretty desperate and will likely be quite terrible

This is the only way to save/end the franchise. Do it

likely be terrible? So what, Matthew and woody show up and they forgot how to act? Nic wrote s1 i trust him if he brings it back.

Nahhh let them cook

Rewatching s1 and Cole speaking nothing but facts throughout

Season 1 was lightning in a bottle with years of deliberation. We can get pizza, Fukunaga, woody and Mathew for a sequel but it just won't capture the same magic

thing is fukunaga will not return and he kinda a bigger part of why sxn 1 was so good than nic

are you a director? I feel like directors are the only people in the world who think directors are more important than a good script

No director, even fukunaga would’ve made the script for season 4 a classic like s1, it’s the writing that makes or breaks it

the truth is that fukunaga ain't all that and nic is also not all that

they completed each other's shortcomings and made something nice.

both ain't s*** but I'll still watch something that involves woody and mcc

starlight played woodys daughter

This is def true for tv yeah, with movies a director can still save a mediocre script imo. Even though I thought season 4 also looked s***.

Lowkey still scared to rewatch season 1, been like 6 years since I first saw it but I fear I might find it corny if I watch now that I’m older

Nah it’s still piff. If you don’t like it you’ve turned into an a******

ngl first ep I was thinking why mcconaughey giving so many monologues and woody tryna be funny like they in 2 different shows but that kinda stopped right after
im bout to finish ep 5 rn and its still gas

still disappointed how great season 1 was how much of a dumpster fire season 2 is

season 3 seemed like something was there but i didnt bother to finish

nah season 3 is great, the final ep is the best. give it another shot someday?

Season 3 ends on a kinda solid note but tbh you saw S1 and thats the peak. Everything else this show has done is either just ok (s3) or downright ass (s2 and s4) so you really not missing anything crazy

If season 5 sucks just throw this show in the trash entirely

People loving the last season says so much about where we and HBO are in our journeys lol

watching the outsider which is lowkey better than most seasons of this series

I rewatched it recently. Holds up still