There is a huge illogical detail in the film that honestly ruined the experience for me a little. I’m going to see it a second time.
How is it possible that Penelope and Eumaeus did not immediately recognize Odysseus by his voice and manner of speaking? He was like a son to Eumaeus, and he was the dearest person in the world to Penelope. Their relationships are hyped up so much - how important they were and still are in each other’s lives through everything. And then suddenly you don’t recognize the voice or mannerisms of the person dearest to you? Ridiculous.
I’ll say this: I would recognize my father’s or mother’s voice instantly. In fact, I recognized my father’s voice immediately even though we had not spoken for around ten years. Would anyone seriously claim otherwise?
I would instantly recognize my wife’s voice and manner of speaking. It would be impossible not to. It was incredibly illogical and frustrating to watch, because there is simply no way you would fail to recognize the voice and speech patterns of the person closest to you.
I have even recognized acquaintances and friends immediately after not speaking to them for many years. But here we are talking about the most important person in someone’s life, and they do not recognize them? Hows that even possible.
Yeah you not supposed to think this hard about it
Its basically a superhero movie based on a 3000 year old comic book
Movie of life
Yeah you not supposed to think this hard about it
Its basically a superhero movie based on a 3000 year old comic book
They’re asking why odysseus can wear a disguise in a movie with giants and cyclops and mermaids
There is a huge illogical detail in the film that honestly ruined the experience for me a little. I’m going to see it a second time.
How is it possible that Penelope and Eumaeus did not immediately recognize Odysseus by his voice and manner of speaking? He was like a son to Eumaeus, and he was the dearest person in the world to Penelope. Their relationships are hyped up so much - how important they were and still are in each other’s lives through everything. And then suddenly you don’t recognize the voice or mannerisms of the person dearest to you? Ridiculous.
I’ll say this: I would recognize my father’s or mother’s voice instantly. In fact, I recognized my father’s voice immediately even though we had not spoken for around ten years. Would anyone seriously claim otherwise?
I would instantly recognize my wife’s voice and manner of speaking. It would be impossible not to. It was incredibly illogical and frustrating to watch, because there is simply no way you would fail to recognize the voice and speech patterns of the person closest to you.
I have even recognized acquaintances and friends immediately after not speaking to them for many years. But here we are talking about the most important person in someone’s life, and they do not recognize them? Hows that even possible.
he was gone for 20 years. it's not that hard to believe that they wouldn't have remembered his voice, especially when memory can be very faulty. here's a review for an unrelated film:

There is a huge illogical detail in the film that honestly ruined the experience for me a little. I’m going to see it a second time.
How is it possible that Penelope and Eumaeus did not immediately recognize Odysseus by his voice and manner of speaking? He was like a son to Eumaeus, and he was the dearest person in the world to Penelope. Their relationships are hyped up so much - how important they were and still are in each other’s lives through everything. And then suddenly you don’t recognize the voice or mannerisms of the person dearest to you? Ridiculous.
I’ll say this: I would recognize my father’s or mother’s voice instantly. In fact, I recognized my father’s voice immediately even though we had not spoken for around ten years. Would anyone seriously claim otherwise?
I would instantly recognize my wife’s voice and manner of speaking. It would be impossible not to. It was incredibly illogical and frustrating to watch, because there is simply no way you would fail to recognize the voice and speech patterns of the person closest to you.
I have even recognized acquaintances and friends immediately after not speaking to them for many years. But here we are talking about the most important person in someone’s life, and they do not recognize them? Hows that even possible.
Greeks can be a little slow
There is a huge illogical detail in the film that honestly ruined the experience for me a little. I’m going to see it a second time.
How is it possible that Penelope and Eumaeus did not immediately recognize Odysseus by his voice and manner of speaking? He was like a son to Eumaeus, and he was the dearest person in the world to Penelope. Their relationships are hyped up so much - how important they were and still are in each other’s lives through everything. And then suddenly you don’t recognize the voice or mannerisms of the person dearest to you? Ridiculous.
I’ll say this: I would recognize my father’s or mother’s voice instantly. In fact, I recognized my father’s voice immediately even though we had not spoken for around ten years. Would anyone seriously claim otherwise?
I would instantly recognize my wife’s voice and manner of speaking. It would be impossible not to. It was incredibly illogical and frustrating to watch, because there is simply no way you would fail to recognize the voice and speech patterns of the person closest to you.
I have even recognized acquaintances and friends immediately after not speaking to them for many years. But here we are talking about the most important person in someone’s life, and they do not recognize them? Hows that even possible.
it's completely logical to forget a voice you haven't heard in 20 years
There is a huge illogical detail in the film that honestly ruined the experience for me a little. I’m going to see it a second time.
How is it possible that Penelope and Eumaeus did not immediately recognize Odysseus by his voice and manner of speaking? He was like a son to Eumaeus, and he was the dearest person in the world to Penelope. Their relationships are hyped up so much - how important they were and still are in each other’s lives through everything. And then suddenly you don’t recognize the voice or mannerisms of the person dearest to you? Ridiculous.
I’ll say this: I would recognize my father’s or mother’s voice instantly. In fact, I recognized my father’s voice immediately even though we had not spoken for around ten years. Would anyone seriously claim otherwise?
I would instantly recognize my wife’s voice and manner of speaking. It would be impossible not to. It was incredibly illogical and frustrating to watch, because there is simply no way you would fail to recognize the voice and speech patterns of the person closest to you.
I have even recognized acquaintances and friends immediately after not speaking to them for many years. But here we are talking about the most important person in someone’s life, and they do not recognize them? Hows that even possible.
Brother its not just the fact they havent heard his voice in 20 years but they also presume he's been DEAD for 20 years too.
If someone who you think been dead for 20 years just randomly came back in a disguise, you're not going to recognize their voice lol. Especially in a time where there's no recordings
it's completely logical to forget a voice you haven't heard in 20 years
Why wouldn’t penelope listen to old voicemails from odysseus if she forgot? Is she stupid?
Why wouldn’t penelope listen to old voicemails from odysseus if she forgot? Is she stupid?
really wish they addressed this
Why wouldn’t penelope listen to old voicemails from odysseus if she forgot? Is she stupid?
why didn't they just use a airplane to get back home? are they stupid?
the moment they realize it was Odysseus was so good, thats what i look forward to most watching again
plucking the bow coinciding with the music
straight aura
plucking the bow coinciding with the music
straight aura
That s*** felt like heroin every time it happened
it's completely logical to forget a voice you haven't heard in 20 years
Lets not forget the fact that this is also a fictional story
it's completely logical to forget a voice you haven't heard in 20 years
No, it isn’t. We’re not talking about some random sound—we’re talking about an entire conversation and someone’s whole way of speaking. Are you seriously trying to tell me that after 20 years of waiting, you wouldn’t recognize your mother, father, sister, or brother if they spoke to you for ten minutes? That you genuinely wouldn’t realize who it was?
Like I said, I know from personal experience. I hadn’t spoken to my father for around ten years, hadn’t heard his voice anywhere or anything, and I recognized him within a second over the phone. And I hadn’t spent those ten years waiting for him to call.
he was gone for 20 years. it's not that hard to believe that they wouldn't have remembered his voice, especially when memory can be very faulty. here's a review for an unrelated film:

Recordings alter our voices, and they affect everyone differently. I don’t even recognize my own voice sometimes, and when several of my friends are talking in a recording, I occasionally can’t tell who is who.
Brother its not just the fact they havent heard his voice in 20 years but they also presume he's been DEAD for 20 years too.
If someone who you think been dead for 20 years just randomly came back in a disguise, you're not going to recognize their voice lol. Especially in a time where there's no recordings
Um, weren’t they all waiting for him to return for 20 years? It’s not like they thought he was dead. They were all waiting for him and literally thinking about him every single day in that context.
No, it isn’t. We’re not talking about some random sound—we’re talking about an entire conversation and someone’s whole way of speaking. Are you seriously trying to tell me that after 20 years of waiting, you wouldn’t recognize your mother, father, sister, or brother if they spoke to you for ten minutes? That you genuinely wouldn’t realize who it was?
Like I said, I know from personal experience. I hadn’t spoken to my father for around ten years, hadn’t heard his voice anywhere or anything, and I recognized him within a second over the phone. And I hadn’t spent those ten years waiting for him to call.
when ur phone called did it say "dad" before u picked up
when ur phone called did it say "dad" before u picked up
No, but yeah, he didn’t start telling me some random story either—I recognized him from his voice immediately. It’s not like I had forgotten what my own father sounded like; that would be impossible :D That’s exactly my point.
If someone had asked me during those years, “Hey, do you think you’d recognize your father’s voice?”, my first reaction would have been: why wouldn’t I? Is it even possible not to? :D I understand not recognizing someone from one random phrase or sentence, but they have long conversations with him in the film.
No, it isn’t. We’re not talking about some random sound—we’re talking about an entire conversation and someone’s whole way of speaking. Are you seriously trying to tell me that after 20 years of waiting, you wouldn’t recognize your mother, father, sister, or brother if they spoke to you for ten minutes? That you genuinely wouldn’t realize who it was?
Like I said, I know from personal experience. I hadn’t spoken to my father for around ten years, hadn’t heard his voice anywhere or anything, and I recognized him within a second over the phone. And I hadn’t spent those ten years waiting for him to call.
just because you have a supposedly eidetic memory does not mean that everyone else does. it's not a foreign concept that someone would forget the sound of a person's voice after 20 years of no contact. this is some cinemasins type of nitpicking
Um, weren’t they all waiting for him to return for 20 years? It’s not like they thought he was dead. They were all waiting for him and literally thinking about him every single day in that context.
They presumed he was dead but still had small hope that maybe he would one day return.
Again its a 20 year interval, if ur dad who you havent spoken to for 20 years came to you hiding the fact that he was your dad....you wouldn't recognize him man cmon now
just because you have a supposedly eidetic memory does not mean that everyone else does. it's not a foreign concept that someone would forget the sound of a person's voice after 20 years of no contact. this is some cinemasins type of nitpicking
So you’re saying that you genuinely wouldn’t realize you had already been talking for ten minutes to your own father or mother—the person you had been waiting 20 years for?
Honestly, this is the only place where people have disagreed with me, which doesn’t surprise me. I’ve brought this up elsewhere too, and most people agree with me 100%.
Maybe 12- or 18-year-olds don’t fully grasp the concept, because it’s tied to time itself. As you get older, you understand that many things aren’t about what you “think” or “remember”—they’re things you simply know.
I know what my mother’s, father’s, or wife’s voice sounds like. That isn’t something you just "forget".