Communism Thread

Page 221 of 1355
Reply
  • Aug 16, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    Alright what the F*** is dialectical materialism

    marxists.org/glossary/terms/d/i.htm

  • Aug 16, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    Here’s a good video explanation as well

  • Aug 17, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    i can't explain dialectical materialism very well, but i know it when i see it

  • Aug 17, 2021
    deadacc

    first step to unfucking aghanistan.

    there's 12 million in resources in the ground, so hopefully w the help of belt and road infrastructure the country can industrialize and the material conditions of the people can improve

    sadly not looking like socialism and taliban characteristics are compatible, given their continued prosecution of socialists, so even with industrialization it is only going to reproduce the inequality in other capitalist countries, but until those contradictions are apparent this is prob the best thing that can happen given the conditions.

    also didn't know this until recently but how bad the british f***ed up the region when they drew their line is insane.

    real accurate work there dumbasses

    im dying at the thought of socialism with Taliban characteristics now im pretty sure the Maoist movement might have had potential but with the death of Zia seemed to put a huge dent on that

  • Aug 17, 2021
    Synopsis

    i can't explain dialectical materialism very well, but i know it when i see it

    It's just something you pick up after reading a lot of Marxist texts

  • Aug 17, 2021

    Marxists should not be afraid of criticism from any quarter. Quite the contrary, they need to temper and develop themselves and win new positions in the teeth of criticism and in the storm and stress of struggle. Fighting against wrong ideas is like being vaccinated -- a man develops greater immunity from disease as a result of vaccination.

    Love Mao writing style so much

  • Aug 17, 2021
    ·
    edited
    ·
    2 replies

    @RxSerpico

    It's a philosophical concept. Dialectics comes from Hegel, materialism comes from ? and Marx mixed the two together to form dialectical materialism

    For example Liberal history teaches you that Africa is underdeveloped, US and EU are rich, and that the slave trade and colonialism happened like 100 years ago. In liberal history, none of this is connected. They are separate events. However with a dialectical materialist viewpoint, you can easily see how the dialectic between development and underdevelopment played out throughout that history.

    So let's try and break the concept down

    materialism = not idealism

    can be applied to history, historical materialism, which is the most eye opening thing ive experienced in my life.

    Marx applies it in all different types of ways, but essentially it's the belief that humans develop through meeting material needs via production rather than thinking/consciousness.

    To give another example, an idealist standpoint in the modern era is one that some anarchists take: Palestine should have a "no state solution". To be materialist is to identify that This is idealist because there is no viable anarchist movement within Palestine, and that it is materially impossible.

    dialectics is harder to explain, it's way of a***yzing a situation to understand the contradictions inherent within the situation. contradictions are what being change, they are the forces of change.

    Dialectics break these into two, there are primary contradictions and secondary contradictions. The primary confiscations modulate the secondary contradictions. Some contradictions are more important than others.

    This means inherently dialectics is the thought of relationships. There is no simple one cause and effect, the causes and effects modulate and cause and effect each there until it is one big spinning wheel that moves so fast you cannot tell which way it's moving.

    You have to view an entire situation from the relationships, not just as a simple "X caused Y." This is something liberals have a hard time with.

    dialectical materialism brings it together and is a concrete way to materially a***yze a situation in order to see the contradictions inherent in order to resolve those contradictions to bring change.

    Hopefully this helps even a bit

  • Aug 17, 2021
    space0cadet
    · edited

    @RxSerpico

    It's a philosophical concept. Dialectics comes from Hegel, materialism comes from ? and Marx mixed the two together to form dialectical materialism

    For example Liberal history teaches you that Africa is underdeveloped, US and EU are rich, and that the slave trade and colonialism happened like 100 years ago. In liberal history, none of this is connected. They are separate events. However with a dialectical materialist viewpoint, you can easily see how the dialectic between development and underdevelopment played out throughout that history.

    So let's try and break the concept down

    materialism = not idealism

    can be applied to history, historical materialism, which is the most eye opening thing ive experienced in my life.

    Marx applies it in all different types of ways, but essentially it's the belief that humans develop through meeting material needs via production rather than thinking/consciousness.

    To give another example, an idealist standpoint in the modern era is one that some anarchists take: Palestine should have a "no state solution". To be materialist is to identify that This is idealist because there is no viable anarchist movement within Palestine, and that it is materially impossible.

    dialectics is harder to explain, it's way of a***yzing a situation to understand the contradictions inherent within the situation. contradictions are what being change, they are the forces of change.

    Dialectics break these into two, there are primary contradictions and secondary contradictions. The primary confiscations modulate the secondary contradictions. Some contradictions are more important than others.

    This means inherently dialectics is the thought of relationships. There is no simple one cause and effect, the causes and effects modulate and cause and effect each there until it is one big spinning wheel that moves so fast you cannot tell which way it's moving.

    You have to view an entire situation from the relationships, not just as a simple "X caused Y." This is something liberals have a hard time with.

    dialectical materialism brings it together and is a concrete way to materially a***yze a situation in order to see the contradictions inherent in order to resolve those contradictions to bring change.

    Hopefully this helps even a bit

    same learning about historical and dialectal materialism was the best part of theory for me.

  • Aug 17, 2021

    dialectical materialism is hella interesting cause it states that all things are always in motion, which means communism wouldn't be the end stage just hopefully the next, so what contradictions would exist in communism that would push it to the next stage, unless we get to live in communism which is not gonna happen in our lifespan we wont know. Also I also find it easy to fall into determinism with these topics which should be avoided like Rosa said Socialism or Barbarism, we aren't guaranteed anything.

  • Aug 17, 2021
    space0cadet
    · edited

    @RxSerpico

    It's a philosophical concept. Dialectics comes from Hegel, materialism comes from ? and Marx mixed the two together to form dialectical materialism

    For example Liberal history teaches you that Africa is underdeveloped, US and EU are rich, and that the slave trade and colonialism happened like 100 years ago. In liberal history, none of this is connected. They are separate events. However with a dialectical materialist viewpoint, you can easily see how the dialectic between development and underdevelopment played out throughout that history.

    So let's try and break the concept down

    materialism = not idealism

    can be applied to history, historical materialism, which is the most eye opening thing ive experienced in my life.

    Marx applies it in all different types of ways, but essentially it's the belief that humans develop through meeting material needs via production rather than thinking/consciousness.

    To give another example, an idealist standpoint in the modern era is one that some anarchists take: Palestine should have a "no state solution". To be materialist is to identify that This is idealist because there is no viable anarchist movement within Palestine, and that it is materially impossible.

    dialectics is harder to explain, it's way of a***yzing a situation to understand the contradictions inherent within the situation. contradictions are what being change, they are the forces of change.

    Dialectics break these into two, there are primary contradictions and secondary contradictions. The primary confiscations modulate the secondary contradictions. Some contradictions are more important than others.

    This means inherently dialectics is the thought of relationships. There is no simple one cause and effect, the causes and effects modulate and cause and effect each there until it is one big spinning wheel that moves so fast you cannot tell which way it's moving.

    You have to view an entire situation from the relationships, not just as a simple "X caused Y." This is something liberals have a hard time with.

    dialectical materialism brings it together and is a concrete way to materially a***yze a situation in order to see the contradictions inherent in order to resolve those contradictions to bring change.

    Hopefully this helps even a bit

    ? = Ludwig Feuerbach
    marxists.org/reference/archive/feuerbach/works/essence

  • Aug 17, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    Alright what the F*** is dialectical materialism

    ppesydney.net/marxs-method-of-political-economy

    found this article off google that does a good job explaining where it came from and why it's a useful a***ytical framework

  • Aug 17, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    Alright what the F*** is dialectical materialism

    i am therefore i think, very simple.

  • Aug 17, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    Tbh I don't think he was asking that q and was really curious about it; I see dialectical materialism memes on Twitter sometimes so that's probably what spurred it

  • Aug 17, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    space0cadet

    Tbh I don't think he was asking that q and was really curious about it; I see dialectical materialism memes on Twitter sometimes so that's probably what spurred it

    No I genuinely wanna know, I’ve seen it in memes too and also in more serious terms and it sounds like something I should know, I don’t know if I have a firm grasp on it yet but these replies have been helpful, it’s kind of how I’ve come to a***yze things anyhow

  • Aug 17, 2021

    just finished correct handling of contradictions among people by Mao. Finished with the main guys for now I plan on reading liberalism a counter history next what do yall think of it?

  • Aug 17, 2021
    NBA GameBoy

    No I genuinely wanna know, I’ve seen it in memes too and also in more serious terms and it sounds like something I should know, I don’t know if I have a firm grasp on it yet but these replies have been helpful, it’s kind of how I’ve come to a***yze things anyhow

  • Aug 17, 2021

    Just found out the US dissident Mumia Abu-Jamal had COVID in April and underwent a successful heart surgery. He's been in prison for 4 decades.

  • Aug 17, 2021

    Someone in here linked an excerpt of a book about the marshall plan / IMF in here.. I think it was @Zulaw

    still have that link/know what im talking about?

    I think it highlighted how NOT exploitative the loans they gave western europe were compared to how exploitative the loans they gave africa were

  • Aug 18, 2021

  • Aug 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply

    I love that one guy on here who thinks every world event is orchestrated by Iran lmao

  • Aug 18, 2021
    ·
    2 replies
    CoqStar

    Here’s a good video explanation as well

    !https://youtu.be/GNHzVeC7jeY

    Been going through this channel and their amazing wish they had way more views than someone like Varsh since this is actually truly educational, never even realised I watched their the tendency of the rate of profit to fall before.

    This video is great especially the start on how they explain in a simple manner on how Soviet Democracy worked.

  • Aug 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Fargo

    I love that one guy on here who thinks every world event is orchestrated by Iran lmao

    Lmaooo link to their posts plz

  • Aug 18, 2021
    ·
    1 reply
    Womanpuncher69

    Been going through this channel and their amazing wish they had way more views than someone like Varsh since this is actually truly educational, never even realised I watched their the tendency of the rate of profit to fall before.

    This video is great especially the start on how they explain in a simple manner on how Soviet Democracy worked.

    !https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byqOHE-37og

    I agree this channel is incredible I’ve been subbed for a while and have revisited videos several times. The truth is guys like vaush will always get more views than something like this because people like the sensationalism or just the reactionary style of content creation (vaush sucks)

    The truth Is Marxism as a science isn’t really super appealing unless you’re interested and it can be rather dense to get into

  • Aug 18, 2021
    Womanpuncher69

    Been going through this channel and their amazing wish they had way more views than someone like Varsh since this is actually truly educational, never even realised I watched their the tendency of the rate of profit to fall before.

    This video is great especially the start on how they explain in a simple manner on how Soviet Democracy worked.

    !https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byqOHE-37og

    You may also like second thoughts which is another YouTube content creator

    He’s one of the few channels I watch regularly (he uploads new videos every Friday)

  • Aug 18, 2021
    CoqStar

    I agree this channel is incredible I’ve been subbed for a while and have revisited videos several times. The truth is guys like vaush will always get more views than something like this because people like the sensationalism or just the reactionary style of content creation (vaush sucks)

    The truth Is Marxism as a science isn’t really super appealing unless you’re interested and it can be rather dense to get into

    ktt2.com/taliban-will-invade-tajkistan-here-is-why-32491790 l

    latest thread from the Iran dude, I like him entertaining poster and I learn s*** about Iran I never knew before.

    and yeah I agree on why Vaush would be more popular cashing on popular topics like meaningless culture war bs, I just didnt know how to put it in a sentence like how you perfectly described.

    and yeah Marxism is a science which many people would find boring dont really blame em, really only nerds and weirdos would find it interesting like most of us

    Also yeah I watch second thought, hes great anti-capitalist channel prob one of the best currently loved how he gave shout out to smaller marxist channels like Bayarea even if I disagree with Bayarea on many topics