nah theyre right

Noticed that too, happened in that other terrible list from a couple of weeks ago.

No Taylor Swift album is Top 50 worthy let alone Top 5

old critics been going for a more poptimist stance for a while to overcompensate for them being less kind to pop in the past hence the overrating of Taylor Swift

sales = quality but unironically

Curtis Jackson?

86 fka twigs - magdalene
74 one direction - four

Not even in the top 100

Or 150. What's going on

Renaiisance is better than lemonade

Blonde at 3

203

I think we need to make Lists illegal in 2026

You can tell it’s forced too when they’re placing Chappell Roan’s and Olivia Rodrigo’s debut albums in the Top 50 despite them being less than 5 years old.

will never understand the beyonce obsession

decent other than folklore at 4 thats obv bait

Lemonade isnt even top 3 Beyonce f*** these guys

They get paid to promote poptimism

Self Titled > Lemonade

Yep. Rolling Stone basically has an actual Swifty reviewing her albums.

I agree with some of the listings but, this is a garbage list. Putting Beyonce-Lemonade #1 is just critics holding on to what suppose to make sense. No one cares and no one cares to agree with them.

kid a too low

Motherfuckers didn't even bother to put GRODT in the Top 20

Idk how anyone thinks lemonade as the greatest album ever