Went back after a year and spun this today. Honestly it aged nicely. Nothing special for Kanye’s overall catalog but they’re some good bops with great production as always. I feel like this project was unfairly s***ted on. How do yall feel about this project today?

Great album

9/10

Rip good don't die

9/10 is crazy

I don't go back to it but songs like Paid and Hoodrat are probably among his best in the 2020s

Very consistent quality type of album

No extreme highs or extreme lows

It's pretty solid all around

Rare to see another hoodrat enjoyer. Also Vultures (the song) aged well

after hearing Carnival again for the first time in months. This s*** is so hype

sky ya know

great project

i think vultures 1 is pretty good.

ye the goat no cap

Not a bad album at all people were hating bcause of ye being ye.

V2 is a nightmare thougggh

real

good taste

i was at one of the listening parties. was a good time

Album mostly carried by Ty$.

True Vultures is among the best on the album if not the best song. In hindsight its crazy that people didnt fw it

kanye sounds so heavenly on that song for no reason lol i love it

no extreme highs but its 1 point away from 10/10 yall got it

keys to my life

Really solid project. 7/10 minimum honestly. Ton of fun verses and beats.

Vultures 2 has some great songs too, but it’s marred by the AI slop.

problematic

vultures 1 >>> ye > jik

It’s f***ing horrible. Irredeemable.

Vultures 2 cool though

Back To Me’s whole feel is still 10/10.

Wish Ye’s verses were better but we take what we can at this point