Yes

If you like Folky type of albums with organic production, then you will like it. It’s a good album overall but not a 10/10 imo.
P4K just loves her. Her last album 8 years ago got a 9. So her comeback album which is good naturally gets a 10.

We'll reconvene in 2030 when they give a 10 to Troy Ave's masterpiece

album might be good but p4k ratings are meaningless

@chelsea and I already knew upon first listen didn’t wait for these mfs

Well this is her 3rd 100 so far so I guess the critics disagree. Most have em up weekends of drops they’re all just initial reactions

imsure its a good album my problems run deeper than that

The Newspaper outro is beautiful

I'd recommend starting with Tidal and listening to her albums in release order

Yup. Frank/The Weeknd/Partynextdoor/Summer Walker/etc. pretty much don't count

I gave it a 10 on first listen but I’m a fan. Thy are critical websites they should have a higher critical standard and allow the music to live more than 3 days.

no one has better album titles

Idler wheel
Extraordinary
Pawn

In order

not even mad at the people hating on this album just pray that one day they'll realize their wrongs and actually realize that they hated on a masterpiece of an album

i here what @02Shaq and other ppl itt are saying. but the RULES are different for these artists and thats why i dont have the motivation to hear this s***.

fiona apple leaves a mistake in the track and its patriarchy-defying "art" (literally what the review says @ one point). if a black artist did that then theyre "lazy".

no order:

grimes
caroline polachek
kilo kish
kero kero bonito
mj
prince
MIA (she count?)
mcr
janelle monae
radiohead

not really a perfect list but on the spot id say thats accurate

but whatever man like i said ill give it a spin.

Yeah I’m realizing now how stupid we all look

you're holding artists accountable to what critics say?

no. f*** the critics. f*** pitchfork.

so dont blame me when yall TITLE the f***ing thread "pitchfork just gave their first 10 since mbdtf" and i say some s***.

Woah what’s this about leaving a mistake in the track?

I’m too tired to give this s*** a listen rn. What you said is facts tho. Let’s say Drake left a mistake on a song And tried to pass It off as an artistic choice. he’d get crucified

wasn't meaningless when dark fantasy got a 10 apparently

Go in order. You'll appreciate the growth