Sep 9, 2023
MrIndigo96
Bruh I felt the same way cause this man Ye has said the most horrendous s*** in the last decade and this album is still held highly critically and amongst common music listeners. Doesn’t mean publications want to spotlight it but when classics are brought up this is still mentionedThe point of the thread is that it gets brought by default when mosy ppl have issues with it. It's getting brought up on the basis that largely critics and publications propped it up after release
Sep 9, 2023IamStillHealthyDo you feel the discussion around the album reflects this?
No. When the album first dropped, it definitely was looked at as a perfect Kanye west album but I have never agreed with this.
Now I would agree that it’s a masterpiece although I don’t think masterpieces have to be perfect.
Sep 9, 2023IamStillHealthyGlad they used their effort and degrees to make the cheapest looking choice possible. The bordering and background makes it look like an obvious undercooked attempt to being thought of as high art. The painting by itself would have far more presence and strength
Whatever you say man
Sep 9, 2023·2 repliesIamStillHealthyIt can be great great and influential while still having garbage on it and not being perfect this is not that hard to understand.
its actually very easy to understand. its like if I say the 72-10 bulls team is a great all time team very influential but they lost 10 games so they were not a perfect 82-0. and went on a rant calling people “literally John Starks”. good job man. what a great a***ysis!
Sep 9, 2023
jynth
@IamStillHealthy
Member since 2023
Sep 9, 2023Shut the f*** up.
- Sep 9, 2023Palestinian Oozi
its actually very easy to understand. its like if I say the 72-10 bulls team is a great all time team very influential but they lost 10 games so they were not a perfect 82-0. and went on a rant calling people “literally John Starks”. good job man. what a great a***ysis!
Glad you understand unlike the vast majority of the ppl filling 18 pages
Sep 10, 2023
Codyperfect no but still a 10/10
This
“10/10” technically doesn’t mean it’s “perfect”
Sep 10, 2023·1 replyIamStillHealthyI can understand that you look fondly back on the days when this album came out and you were cool, but those days are long gone and its time to admit that MBDTF has a solid amount of garbage on it. 10/10 is a lie
This is not garbage that I'm neatly picking out or fabricating but garbage we all agree on yet seem to ignore when it comes to assessing this album's quality. Why?
Let's be real, most of the people here are not really into rap music that came out before the year 2010. You are all early 2010s fantano and pitchfork babies that are so repulsed by this reality that you have turned your entire sense of self on being a person that hates that current music crowd but share 80-100% of their opinions. The 20% difference is reserved for the brockhampton hate, which is hilarious because you literally are brockhampton
TLDR: you are a b****
Now lets get on to the most obvious garbage on this album.
All of the Lights
The fergie verse is ass. We all know this. no perfect masterpiece has this horseshit on it.
Monster
This song is by and large garbage. The Jay-Z verse on here is horrible. We all know this. The Kanye p**** in a sarcophagus line belongs in a awful hopsin, tech n9ne or a modern eminem verse.
So Appalled
RZA is arguably one of the greatest rap producers of all time but decided to lose some chromosomes for the outro of this s***.
Blame Game
John Legend is a disease and the outro skit on here can't be relistened to. Obvious imperfection.
Also let's talk about the album cover. I'm tired of hearing this s*** be referenced as high art or something when it has the cheapest red paint backdrop texture and the gold border looks like it was made in powerpoint. They had the money to do this s*** for real.
MBDTF is a great album which had a good amount of influence on major rap releases of the mid 2010s but it's time we stop calling it perfect when we none of us really believe that.
For those of you that are gonna complain about reading all this its not my fault the youtube algorithm and p*** have destroyed your attention span. Let's keep this chat positive.
most of the people here are not really into rap music that came out before the year 2010. You are all early 2010s fantano and pitchfork babies
Think you just described yourself bro
- Sep 10, 2023·1 reply
Aw man, is my sarcasm not coming through on this post?
- Sep 10, 2023Rockstard
most of the people here are not really into rap music that came out before the year 2010. You are all early 2010s fantano and pitchfork babies
Think you just described yourself bro
"No u"
Sep 10, 2023KTT2 btw
Sep 10, 2023
Sep 10, 2023IamStillHealthyYou like that fergie verse?
It was a classic like everything else
Sep 10, 2023·1 replyIamStillHealthySolid chance you are
don’t project
Sep 10, 2023its a solid 9.055 not perfect tho
Sep 10, 2023·1 replyAn album can have imperfections and still be 10/10 nothing is “perfect”
Sep 10, 2023fergie was absolutely great on that song, you just hate female pop singers
Sep 10, 2023Thøm BjörkAn album can have imperfections and still be 10/10 nothing is “perfect”
- Sep 10, 2023good boy
don’t project
It's just math
SWAN 💜Sep 10, 2023Its below mid
Proof Ye stans will eat up anything he s***s out
- Sep 10, 2023
vagabonds@op wanna be different so f***ing bad
What you on about it's pretty popular opinion to think that the jay z verse on monster is dumb
