Reply
  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    I’ve never seen a movie that has all the constant ridiculous situations of a comedy but (almost) none of the actual humor of a comedy, honestly it was kind of impressive. I liked it but it wasn’t the best version of this script. If the plot was focused way more on ping pong and way less on trying to afford plane tickets I think I would’ve like it a lot more. The soundtrack and the performances were doing all the heavy lifting, the script needed work.

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Oscar Winner

    What do you think stops it from being a straight forward narrative? Is it cus it’s not “go to the tournament, go home, get money, train, go to the next tournament” but rather it dives into all the different sub plots and kinda seems like it gets lost at times?

    Like some might think “what does this dog s*** gotta do with ping pong”?

    Yeah it’s kinda like random event propels him toward something rather than a character getting from set piece to set piece. Like he falls out of a tub out of nowhere and that kicks off a whole plot that really has nothing to do with the tourney but it’s also how he gets his money for the tourney at the same time. It’s interesting… the threads that are weaved. It makes sense and it doesn’t

  • Dec 26, 2025
    maxxing

    I’ve never seen a movie that has all the constant ridiculous situations of a comedy but (almost) none of the actual humor of a comedy, honestly it was kind of impressive. I liked it but it wasn’t the best version of this script. If the plot was focused way more on ping pong and way less on trying to afford plane tickets I think I would’ve like it a lot more. The soundtrack and the performances were doing all the heavy lifting, the script needed work.

    Not mad at this

  • Dec 26, 2025

    It's Marty Supreme, It's Marty Supreme, It's Marty SUPREME

  • Dec 26, 2025

    I had a blast and the ending gave all of the insanity some humanity and catharsis. Wouldn't rank it ahead of Uncut Gems and I think the Safdies have had tighter scripts, but the execution here is pretty flawless from a production standpoint and none of the performances took me out of it. Just really high quality entertainment and it's pretty incredible how far Josh has come since Heaven Knows What from a budget standpoint.

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    edited
    Oscar Winner

    Still can’t get over what that ball morphed from

    Watched that s*** with my mom lmaooooo

    (She loved the movie)

  • Dec 26, 2025

    Another 2 months 😪

  • going again saturday

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    rustcohlestan2

    for me it’s:

    OBAA
    marty supreme
    sinners

    everything else

    My Top 10:

    1. One Battle After Another
    2. Hamnet
    3. Eddington
    4. Sinners
    5. Marty Supreme
    6. 28 Years Later
    7. Cloud
    8. The Secret Agent
    9. Ne Zha 2
    10. Mickey 17

  • Dec 26, 2025
    rustcohlestan2

    for me it’s:

    OBAA
    marty supreme
    sinners

    everything else

    Oooooomf idk if I could put over sinners. Honestly the whole dog scene s*** kinda just puts it at number 3 for me after OBAA and sinners. Like I felt like in Marty Supreme there was several times we coulda did without a few scenes. However pacing was still fine to me

  • Dec 26, 2025
  • tonight 6:30 central standard time 😊

  • Dec 26, 2025

    What an awful person man that was great

  • Dec 26, 2025
  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    nahmias.com/collections/marty-supreme-all

    surely this link means they are getting ready to drop the jacket any minute now

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ROBO DOG

    https://nahmias.com/collections/marty-supreme-all

    surely this link means they are getting ready to drop the jacket any minute now

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    The humor is definitely here idk how you don’t find this movie funny

  • Dec 26, 2025
    NobodyWins

    The humor is definitely here idk how you don’t find this movie funny

    Bro this s*** was mad funny while trying not to be funny

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    I think most complaints will be “nobody was likable” and the casuals will say there’s no story despite there being a lot of story.

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply

    The orange balls didn’t have much significance

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    NobodyWins

    I think most complaints will be “nobody was likable” and the casuals will say there’s no story despite there being a lot of story.

    It’s about a man who wants to be the world champ, he loses his first tournament, goes home, has life hit him in the ass, needs to find money to go to the second tournament, finally does, and finally beats the guy who beat him.

    Sounds like a story to me

    Safdies and guys like Sean Baker try to hide plot points as much as possible so it’s not so cliche and in your face; but it’s there. The story is there.

  • Dec 26, 2025
    R1D1

    The orange balls didn’t have much significance

    But you felt it

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Oscar Winner

    It’s about a man who wants to be the world champ, he loses his first tournament, goes home, has life hit him in the ass, needs to find money to go to the second tournament, finally does, and finally beats the guy who beat him.

    Sounds like a story to me

    Safdies and guys like Sean Baker try to hide plot points as much as possible so it’s not so cliche and in your face; but it’s there. The story is there.

    I dont get the no story stuff at all lol. Then they’ll praise uncut gems or good time when it’s similar in structure.

    how did you enjoy watching them chase a dog for an hour? Meanwhile they’ll then say good time was way better when 1/3rd of that was tracking down a bottle of acid.

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    ilgnd

    Yeah it’s kinda like random event propels him toward something rather than a character getting from set piece to set piece. Like he falls out of a tub out of nowhere and that kicks off a whole plot that really has nothing to do with the tourney but it’s also how he gets his money for the tourney at the same time. It’s interesting… the threads that are weaved. It makes sense and it doesn’t

    I feel you, but at the same time the hotel clerk told him do not use the shower cus it’s messed up and Marty didn’t listen. So obviously there is the randomness of the guy and dog getting crushed and it being timed that way (even tho he said ima wash the dog rn), but it stems from Marty’s character being stubborn and not listening

  • Dec 26, 2025
    ·
    edited
    Oscar Winner

    I feel you, but at the same time the hotel clerk told him do not use the shower cus it’s messed up and Marty didn’t listen. So obviously there is the randomness of the guy and dog getting crushed and it being timed that way (even tho he said ima wash the dog rn), but it stems from Marty’s character being stubborn and not listening

    Yeah its all there. really it’s just a movie about a hustler finding the way. I gotta walk back what I said a little.