Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    2 replies
    deleteduser579

    Sales thread really changed the site

    Debates used to be about which artists had more classics

    Now it’s about which artist has sold more records

    The Poptification of KTT

  • Oct 9, 2025
    deleteduser579

    Sales thread really changed the site

    Ehh

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    kasich2028

    Well guess what? When MJ died, he moved 35 million albums in 12 months afterwards.

    Taylor sold 48 million albums in 2023. So MJ really wont win against TS with these hypothetical scenarios. There is no bigger boosts than the postmortem sales hike.

    You’re saying this like MJ didn’t have a crazy fanbase like Taylor currently has lol

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    deleteduser579

    You’re saying this like MJ didn’t have a crazy fanbase like Taylor currently has lol

    MJ lost his biggest market after the allegations, which was his 14th mainstream solo career year.

    Taylor started getting bigger and bigger in the US in her 14th year and shows no signs of stopping.

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Free YoungBoy

    Comparing a posthumous bump to a prime year is stupid

    Wasn't that his biggest year in terms of sales?

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Midzy

    Wasn't that his biggest year in terms of sales?

    Not just his biggest year, but the record selling year at the time

  • Botney

    MJ lost his biggest market after the allegations, which was his 14th mainstream solo career year.

    Taylor started getting bigger and bigger in the US in her 14th year and shows no signs of stopping.

    That’s not really relevant as no one was comparing who remained hotter in their careers, the post was referring to exploiting one’s fanbase to hike numbers and in order to do that you need a rabid and dedicated fanbase

    MJ was the biggest and most impactful pop artist of his day, (if not ever) if he really wanted to do what Taylor did with all of these different variants and the like he definitely could’ve

  • Oct 9, 2025
    kasich2028

    Not just his biggest year, but the record selling year at the time

    That's tough. She took that one with ease.

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    3 replies

    They hate her because she’s the biggest artist of 3 generations. Charli released 40 variants for Brat but it was a “Brat summer” so nobody cared.

    They also severely overestimate how many fans are buying multiple copies of an album during a recession.

    Just look at the numbers for the eras tour. It says it all. There are millions of swift fans who don’t even buy her music AT ALL. Me included. I have never once bought a Taylor album but I did spend 7k on two tickets for the eras tour.

    Yall really can’t even fathom her reach and popularity.

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    Harlem

    They hate her because she’s the biggest artist of 3 generations. Charli released 40 variants for Brat but it was a “Brat summer” so nobody cared.

    They also severely overestimate how many fans are buying multiple copies of an album during a recession.

    Just look at the numbers for the eras tour. It says it all. There are millions of swift fans who don’t even buy her music AT ALL. Me included. I have never once bought a Taylor album but I did spend 7k on two tickets for the eras tour.

    Yall really can’t even fathom her reach and popularity.

    That’s the funny part, everything points to Taylor being the biggest artist ever this decade, she’s got

    -The most streams
    -The most sales
    The biggest tour
    -She’s about to surpass Madonna as the best selling female artist ever next week
    -will surpass MJ as the best selling solo act within a few years
    The Beatle’s record 134 weeks at #1 is reachable for her
    -And now will take the biggest album debut, Despite the sales market being dead.

    Like she’s demolishing every records that your faves aren’t even close to reaching, so y’all haters should just stfu lol

  • Oct 9, 2025
  • Oct 9, 2025

    Remember when R*an M*rphy did this parody of Taylor and her fans in 2015?

    Tbh, Taylor and her fans have always been like this... she just gamefied their behavior and buying her albums multiple times became an important part of being a swiftie

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Harlem

    They hate her because she’s the biggest artist of 3 generations. Charli released 40 variants for Brat but it was a “Brat summer” so nobody cared.

    They also severely overestimate how many fans are buying multiple copies of an album during a recession.

    Just look at the numbers for the eras tour. It says it all. There are millions of swift fans who don’t even buy her music AT ALL. Me included. I have never once bought a Taylor album but I did spend 7k on two tickets for the eras tour.

    Yall really can’t even fathom her reach and popularity.

    Just look at the numbers for the eras tour. It says it all. There are millions of swift fans who don’t even buy her music AT ALL. Me included. I have never once bought a Taylor album but I did spend 7k on two tickets for the eras tour.

    This is literally just because of demographics

    Taylor doesn’t even have the highest attended tour of all time btw

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    kasich2028

    That’s the funny part, everything points to Taylor being the biggest artist ever this decade, she’s got

    -The most streams
    -The most sales
    The biggest tour
    -She’s about to surpass Madonna as the best selling female artist ever next week
    -will surpass MJ as the best selling solo act within a few years
    The Beatle’s record 134 weeks at #1 is reachable for her
    -And now will take the biggest album debut, Despite the sales market being dead.

    Like she’s demolishing every records that your faves aren’t even close to reaching, so y’all haters should just stfu lol

    Taylor Swift started 2025 10 billion streams behind Drake on Spotify

    She is currently 10 billion streams behind Drake on Spotify

    Bad Bunny will surpass her before she comes within 5B of Drake

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    edited
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Taylor Swift started 2025 10 billion streams behind Drake on Spotify

    She is currently 10 billion streams behind Drake on Spotify

    Bad Bunny will surpass her before she comes within 5B of Drake

    I meant most streams as in most streams in a single year. The reason she is behind on Spotify is she wasn’t on Spotify for years, this is pretty well known already.

    She will take the overall record at some point

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    This is not true whatsoever.

    Harry Potter is the fourth highest grossing film franchise of all-time at $9.6B

    Spider-Man is second all-time at $11B.

    Now adjust for inflation lol

    without inflation Harry Potter 1 outgrossed spiderman homecoming, spiderman 2002 and the amazing spiderman 😭

  • goretex 💁🏽‍♂️
    Oct 9, 2025
    TheFader

    Debates used to be about which artists had more classics

    Now it’s about which artist has sold more records

    The Poptification of KTT

  • Oct 9, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    This is not true whatsoever

    Spider-Man is arguably the most popular media character of all time behind like Mickey Mouse and that’s it

    harry potter got a theme park

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
  • Oct 10, 2025
    kasich2028

    I meant most streams as in most streams in a single year. The reason she is behind on Spotify is she wasn’t on Spotify for years, this is pretty well known already.

    She will take the overall record at some point

    No she won’t

    Bad Bunny didn’t even drop his debut album until 2018 and he’s already #3, he’s gonna be #1 within a year or two

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Mafia Boss

    Now adjust for inflation lol

    without inflation Harry Potter 1 outgrossed spiderman homecoming, spiderman 2002 and the amazing spiderman 😭

    Why you adjusting for inflation for two movies that dropped within months of each other?

    Sorcerer’s Stone - November 2001

    Spider-Man 1 - May 2002

    Also the whole “adjusted for inflation” thing when it comes to movies’ box office is the biggest crock of horseshit that doesn’t mean anything

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Mafia Boss

    harry potter got a theme park

    Harry Potter is an entire universe, Spider-Man is one singular character

    A Spider-Man theme park wouldn’t make any logistical sense whatsoever lmao

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    2 replies
    TheFader

    Debates used to be about which artists had more classics

    Now it’s about which artist has sold more records

    The Poptification of KTT

    Once again, this thread initially was a set up by the OP to get Kendrick clowned for the MMTBS release after a few people on Twitter made unrealistic sales predictions.

    She still denies this every time I bring this up but people who were around before this got pinned into a mega thread know what I'm talking about.

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Bobby_96

    Once again, this thread initially was a set up by the OP to get Kendrick clowned for the MMTBS release after a few people on Twitter made unrealistic sales predictions.

    She still denies this every time I bring this up but people who were around before this got pinned into a mega thread know what I'm talking about.

    for it to be a setup, wouldn't she have had to know that mr morale would be a flop? thats quite a foresight

  • Oct 10, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Blue Man

    for it to be a setup, wouldn't she have had to know that mr morale would be a flop? thats quite a foresight

    The tweets she reposted had very unrealistic expectations like 600k or 800k fw which everybody knew wasn't expected of him.

Thread was locked by
a moderator