Thread was locked by
a moderator
  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    iHype

    …I never said one listen should count as one sale.

    I don’t have an issue with the way a streaming unit counts. It’s reflective of revenue mostly in comparison to a sale. At the end of the day labels are measuring success based on revenue.

    I just clarified that you can absolutely argue music is more popular than ever in terms of population reach but that’s something which a unit doesn’t necessarily reflect.

    But you can’t because there was no way to quantify how many people were listening to music on a daily basis before streaming.

    Streaming tracks LISTENING

    Sales track PURCHASES

    Streaming has also inflated popular albums’ sales because of the concept of indefinite sales. An album like Scorpion will probably move close to a million units every 2-4 years for the next 30+ years at minimum because streaming exists. But that was literally impossible before streaming

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    But you can’t because there was no way to quantify how many people were listening to music on a daily basis before streaming.

    Streaming tracks LISTENING

    Sales track PURCHASES

    Streaming has also inflated popular albums’ sales because of the concept of indefinite sales. An album like Scorpion will probably move close to a million units every 2-4 years for the next 30+ years at minimum because streaming exists. But that was literally impossible before streaming

    Right… you assume Scorpion will still be casually listened to by millions of people 30+ years later because streaming has made albums more widely consumed and available than ever 😭

  • Oct 4, 2025
    mangotflu

    i remember everyone used to think streaming would kill albums

    but it feels like albums are now bigger than ever

    I feel like it killed listening to physical albums. I think there was a study saying most people who buy vinyls dont have vinyl player

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Drake is the biggest rap artist of all time, arguably.

    Kendrick Lamar has the biggest rap song of both the 2010s and the 2020s.

    Both of these statements are true at the same time. It is not disrespect to the other one to admit the truth of each of these statements

    Disagree on biggest rap song of 2010s if you saying thats goosebumps.

    highest certified ≠ biggest

  • Oct 4, 2025
    e t

    Drake has only 3 solo diamond singles. The rest either have features or are features.

    certified yes but he was more that are eligible.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    2 replies

    But KTT told me R&B doesn’t perform well commercially I’m confused

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Mafia Boss

    Disagree on biggest rap song of 2010s if you saying thats goosebumps.

    highest certified ≠ biggest

    Wait… so now it’s not just statistics and certifications that tell us what the biggest songs are?

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    iHype

    Right… you assume Scorpion will still be casually listened to by millions of people 30+ years later because streaming has made albums more widely consumed and available than ever 😭

    It’s one of the most popular albums of all time—why would it not be still listened to 30 years later?

  • Oct 4, 2025
    TheFader

    I promise you that more people heard Thriller during its opening week than the amount of people that heard The Tortured Poets Department during its opening week

    You are severely misinterpreting the data

    50x more people can listen to an album now but it wouldn’t count 50x as much.

    And back then, someone could’ve spun Thriller 100 times on its opening day, but it wouldn’t have counted as 99 extra sales.

    people were also more communal so people could burn cds and share them lol

  • Oct 4, 2025
    TheFader

    They honestly should’ve always kept them separate and never even came up with the concept of streaming equivalent units

    Like “streams” should’ve been the new measure of engagement and sales should’ve just remained a separate thing

    People would be trying to compare though. Plus billboard is a business once stan culture reached new peaks a few years ago they started charging to see the secondary charts

  • Oct 4, 2025
  • Oct 4, 2025
    TheFader

    Wait… so now it’s not just statistics and certifications that tell us what the biggest songs are?

    For a whole decade? no lol. Part of 2010s is pre streaming.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    TheFader

    But KTT told me R&B doesn’t perform well commercially I’m confused

    https://twitter.com/brianzisook/status/1974566245191287265

    I mean it really doesnt compared to rap.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 4, 2025

    It’s insane Drake has that many streams but will always be known as that creep that lost to Kendrick Lamar

  • Oct 4, 2025
  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    2 replies
    Blue Man
    https://twitter.com/HipHopAllDayy/status/1973781383714611657

    Oof.. over double Kendrick. Wtf.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Big Dog

    Oof.. over double Kendrick. Wtf.

    Why do y’all still say stuff like this in shock? Drake is arguably the most popular rapper ever, Kendrick isn’t.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    It’s one of the most popular albums of all time—why would it not be still listened to 30 years later?

    There wasn’t millions of people still revisiting MC Hammer, Vanilla Ice, etc albums that went Diamond in future decades. They were taken off the shelves after their initial run, collected dust in people’s houses, and people kept it pushing. Absolutely nobody remembered them or was still replaying those CDs by the 2000s lol.

    Any big album in the 2010s/2020s is basically gonna stay on rotation to some degree and get revisited by millions each year.

    Hell even Fetty Wap got songs from that 2015 album going viral again and recharting in 2025 and that’s the closest thing to a 90s Rap fad in that time.

    Graduation, Take Care, Good Kid, etc are literally being introduced to millions of new people every year with a whole new generation cause streaming. It was very rare for albums to have that type of cross-generational life before streaming. Same with Taylor’s discography revival.

    Albums have an unlimited shelf life now and keep reaching millions and millions every year with streaming. As I said before newer albums just haven’t had the time yet to comparably have those trajectories.

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    TheFader

    Why do y’all still say stuff like this in shock? Drake is arguably the most popular rapper ever, Kendrick isn’t.

    Bruh I literally only do it to troll LMFAO

  • Oct 4, 2025
    iHype

    There wasn’t millions of people still revisiting MC Hammer, Vanilla Ice, etc albums that went Diamond in future decades. They were taken off the shelves after their initial run, collected dust in people’s houses, and people kept it pushing. Absolutely nobody remembered them or was still replaying those CDs by the 2000s lol.

    Any big album in the 2010s/2020s is basically gonna stay on rotation to some degree and get revisited by millions each year.

    Hell even Fetty Wap got songs from that 2015 album going viral again and recharting in 2025 and that’s the closest thing to a 90s Rap fad in that time.

    Graduation, Take Care, Good Kid, etc are literally being introduced to millions of new people every year with a whole new generation cause streaming. It was very rare for albums to have that type of cross-generational life before streaming. Same with Taylor’s discography revival.

    Albums have an unlimited shelf life now and keep reaching millions and millions every year with streaming. As I said before newer albums just haven’t had the time yet to comparably have those trajectories.

    Which is a great thing, nobody is denying that.

    But we also have to acknowledge when talking about these modern albums’ sales that they benefit from being in an era where album continue to sell forever. Older albums did not have that same luxury for decades

  • Oct 4, 2025
    Big Dog

    Bruh I literally only do it to troll LMFAO

    At least you can admit it gotta respect that

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    3 replies
    Big Dog

    Oof.. over double Kendrick. Wtf.

    yep fader was yapping too much so i had to remind everyone how big the gap is still

  • Oct 4, 2025
    ·
    1 reply
    Blue Man

    yep fader was yapping too much so i had to remind everyone how big the gap is still

    I think I’ve said at least 25 times in this thread that Drake is the biggest rapper of all time, arguably. You don’t have to remind anyone of that, nigga we know

  • Gosh 😹
    Oct 4, 2025
    TheFader

    I think I’ve said at least 25 times in this thread that Drake is the biggest rapper of all time, arguably. You don’t have to remind anyone of that, nigga we know

    At this point it's just to remind themselves of the old days

Thread was locked by
a moderator