what’s changed since the reformulation? i smelled a few years ago and enjoyed it i was thinking of just buying it from a discounter

why do the atomizers on bdk samples suck so much

Perfumed Oil sold,

Other 2 still available

Mancera Red Tobacco
PDM Carlisle

these two are great tobacco frags, but they are pretty similar. Carlisle definitely smoother tho.

Herod is amazing, but I dont think there is a tobacco note.

Herod smells like cherry flavoured shisha tobacco to me. Has a hay-like undertone too from the tobacco

you might be right

Herod is difficult to place my finger on. It's like the most pleasant, softest smelling vanilla scent. It's a 10/10

@op golden soir or angels share?

asked this a while ago but if you had to choose which would you pick?

man i just love smelling stuff. so fun

man i love coromandel

all i need is one spray

the top notes are so overly layered w tobacco and it drys down like that
smells like a backwood
before it was a balance now tghe tobacco beatin the vanille ass
i was a huge fan of it and was my fav TF
finally copped after yrs of smellin but it was def not the same
i returned TV and copped FF instead

no wonder i copped

yupp one of my fav past times for sure
finding the magic after smelling over 50 frags is undefeated

Both are in my top 6 so thats hard tbh. Just depends on what youre after. Grand Soir is resin, amber, vanilla. Slight caramel and (white) chocolate touches. Very classy fragrance. Angels Share is a full on gourmand; cinnamon, apple pie, praline, vanilla.

Thanks. Ima go try to get a sample and not blind buy. Don’t wanna keep being impulsive so I’ll get around to it. Appreciate ya man

Always fam. Def sample first

Damn I cant wait to try these

Feeling left out

r u asking me or tml ?

personally i lov both, forgot grand soir lol
angels share i feel is more versatile but price of grand soir is much better
both 10/10 tho

Omg I need the Ginger one

im not a fragrance warrior like most of u in this thread but i have a bunch now and find myself consistently going for

Bvlgari Théa Rouge edp
Tom Ford Ombre Leather
Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male EDP
Margiela By The Fireplace

Talking of shisha…did you try The Moon yet? i know that thing is nuclear. Literally the strongest fragrance i tried in my life. Love the raspberry in that one

@proper try to find a sample of The Moon somewhere…just trust me you could love it (also Promise if you like the smell of apple cider)

We still love you <3

Just tried L'Immensite, disappointed tbh. Smells like a mall-type freshie. Will stick to Imagination tbh

Was asking both broski thanks for the reply. I’m gonna see if I can go catch a whiff somewhere n a sample b4 I buy killian

Yea thank u. Wanted to buy the travel size of angels share but I was like if I don’t like this that’s fifty beans in the Garbo!