yeah they're connected to the album, but just not elements of the album itself. which i like to discuss mainly about music. but i also like to discuss tangential aspects of this music sometimes

TPAB overrated but a classic as well for me. honestly still cant believe he wanted to put all that stupid poem/2pac s*** in there and thought it sounded good

cant see

Ok i getchu but I don't think calling it overrated is a disconnect from criticism. If anything, it's a starting point to discuss, especially for an album like TPAB because many just assume everybody loves the album. Calling it overrated is a precursor to discussing the elements of the album I dislike

bro lmao Joanna Newsom is one of the “tastemaker” favs, she has been her entire career. to say otherwise is a bit ignorant

she makes great music tho so it makes sense

She appears on year end lists but I rarely see her getting talked about in albums of the decade on the internet. To say otherwise would be a bit ignorant

That one album of hers is always popping up on "greatest of" type lists. Dont even know why this is a discussion.

Which album is that and what lists are putting it in the top 10

Dude this s*** is everywhere

Even I own that album lmao

Only because of me though

You would not know s*** about Joanna without this thread

She's married to f***ing Andy Samberg

P4K gave that s*** a 9 and I've seem ads for her albums all over NYC. Joanna is not the underground nobody you seem to think she is

Never said she was a f***ing nobody, I just said she doesn't get monumental hype but maybe my location and exposure to stuff is different than f***ing NYC. She married Samberg after the higher acclaimed albums so maybe she's received more hype since then.

And I'll take the L because Ys and HOoM are both top 25 in the RYM charts for their decades.

F*** yourself

were you ever sure? no, no, no, not with me

i bet this Twigs album hits different drunk, def sounds like one of those. it’s been growing on me heavy tho, so glad she released an album this good finally. LP1 is like child’s play compared to this

deadpeg so drunk he deleted his avi

Yea LP1 def her weakest effort overall

got em

Bro I never claimed to be unique or a snowflake for liking Joanna Newsom. I just didn't think she got a s***load of attention like other artists this decade.

You ain't even fam

I never said the public reception swayed my opinion on albums, all I said was reception to an album in comparison to my own opinion on an album can warrant a reaction to call it overrated/underrated. Were you even reading what I said

Damn yall overreact like it's nothing hey? All I said was I didn't think Joanna Newsom got as much love for end of decade lists/ wasn't super hyped up and yall read it as me thinking I'm unique for liking her music. Shut the f*** up and read