I'm no scaruffi acolyte but he might be on to something
I thought you were already a big Faust fan
So question... and forgive me if this was asked already somewhere and I missed your answer: The rules are clear enough for me, with the exception of one artist who isn't on your cheat sheet (unless im blind) so i figured i'd ask haha
Young Thug — At the risk of implying that Wikipedia is some kind of "authority", it separates his discog between mixtapes, "commercial mixtapes", and studio albums. Where his first "commercial mixtape" is Barter 6. His first studio album is So Much Fun (which seems really odd to me tbh). So which one would you rule as his debut in your opinion?
To complicate things even further with him, there's the case of Beautiful Thugger Girls, which Thug has consistently called an album but his label defines as another commercial mixtape lol
for the sake of consistency unfortunately it's So Much Fun. I know, I wish I could pick B6 too but I don't wanna start bending definitions for certain artists and not others or make exceptions
1. Faust - Faust
2. The Velvet Underground & Nico
3. The Doors - The Doors
4. Pere Ubu - The Modern Dance
5. Red Crayola - Parable Of Arable Land
6. Klaus Schulze - Irrlicht
7. Morphine - Good
8. NEU! - NEU!
9. Suicide - Suicide
10. Pop Group - Y
11. Butthole Surfers - Psychic, Powerless and another Man's Sac
12. Fugazi - Repeater
13. Mercury Rev - Yerself Is Steam
14. Gun Club - Fire Of Love
15. Red House Painters - Down Colorful Hill
16. Captain Beafheart & His Magic Band - Safe As Milk
17. Hash Jar Tempo - Well Oiled
18. Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds - From Her To Eternity
19. Pandora's Box - Original Sin
20. The Dream Syndicate - The Days Of Wine & Roses
21. King Crimson - In The Court Of The Crimson King
22. Leonard Cohen - Songs Of Leonard Cohen
23. Cop Shoot Cop - Consumer Revolt
24. Pink Floyd - The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
25. Big Black - Atomizer
26. Pixies - Surfer Rosa
27. Dead Kennedys - Fresh Fruit For Rotten Vegetables
28. Mothers Of Invention - Freak Out!
29. Soft Boys - Underwater Moonlight
30. Jon Hassell - Vernal Equinox
31. Residents - Meet The Residents
I thought it was a minimum of 50, or did that change?
I thought it was a minimum of 50, or did that change?
that's copy paste scaruffi list
not his actual list. min 50
for the sake of consistency unfortunately it's So Much Fun. I know, I wish I could pick B6 too but I don't wanna start bending definitions for certain artists and not others or make exceptions
No prob haha just wanted to check! The whole "commercial mixtape" trend from the 2010s is so dumb
rasie tryna sneak young thug into every list
Barter 6 or BTG deserve a spot in my top 80 if they qualified
that's copy paste scaruffi list
not his actual list. min 50
Lol oh makes much more sense
No prob haha just wanted to check! The whole "commercial mixtape" trend from the 2010s is so dumb
haha yeah they don't come close to following the tradition of an actual mixtape. same thing with XXX by Danny Brown. it says it's a mixtape and Old is the second album. so dumb altogether
Lol oh makes much more sense
you know it's not real cause Pandora's Box isn't top 1
I thought you were already a big Faust fan
Huge but i hadn't considered their debut to be the greatest debut
Meadow Meal is the hardest s*** of all time
Huge but i hadn't considered their debut to be the greatest debut
Meadow Meal is the hardest s*** of all time
among the Holy Trinity of only 3 Scaruffi 9.5s. I disagree with 2 of them but it's w/e
We've been on Letterboxd for 10+ years

coming up on 11
first batch I ever logged

to deny
i actually have it on vinyl 
but honestly i had a huge experimental phase in my early 20s and I'm less partial to experimental and especially krautrock these days. still a cool vinyl though i probably won't ever sell it
i actually have it on vinyl 
but honestly i had a huge experimental phase in my early 20s and I'm less partial to experimental and especially krautrock these days. still a cool vinyl though i probably won't ever sell it
You should be gifting this to me if you find it hard to listen to
Maybe I got something to trade
You should be gifting this to me if you find it hard to listen to
Maybe I got something to trade
send your record list
coming up on 11
first batch I ever logged

I used to log s*** all the time I need to get back on my movies
I used to log s*** all the time I need to get back on my movies
I haven't logged much lately cause I'm gaming alot and balls deep in this anime show