RT

Malice is still this year’s mvp but it’s very specific s*** said this album that’s evoked tears lol.

not even close

Niggas was moved to tears off this...?

someone in here said their dad has cancer so no more old men had them feel a way

Niggas really be astounded other people relate to an artist just because they not fans of them.

Oh brother give it a f***in rest.

pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/chance-the-rapper-star-line

5.9 from p4k (guess who did the review)

If I can be real, I enjoy this more as a full body of work

But Clipse has So Be It which is rap song of the decade for me

One of the most beautiful rap albums I’ve heard in a long time

Corny

just found out my dog was a cat

For folks who purchased the CD (as a nigga is about to do soon), it doesn't have Pretty on it.

This cornball Alphonse needs to be stopped

Just retire from reviewing rap if you don’t feel it no more man

The Big Day 6.9 btw.

alphonese gotta be a troll man

He keeps giving the most generic no name underground rappers who are basically just Veeze clones 7s and 8s. But the artists who actually try with their projects and give variety and creativity with their projects he'll toss em 5s or 6s.

I know his exact type lol got the same tastes as a white teenager who just discovered rap and desperately wants to fit in with a particular crowd.

A lower score than big day is actually insane, aggregated scores or not

so glad that my first time listening to this album started with Speed of Love

have been spinning that s*** 4x a day

ngl Back To the Go caught me slippin a lil. i was a major Chance hater before this album so its no bias, but that s*** resonated with me so much. had to actually move back with my mom earlier this decade and needed to reset & focus on my next move so him making a song exactly about that hit too close to home for me

yeah this got me too

Aight I don't care much for the album but when it comes to the P4K review...

"In the six years since his last album, the Chicago rapper has gone through the ringer. Star Line captures a new era of transformation and personal growth, but it too often feels self-conscious and shallow."

Like...what does this even mean bruh lmao you acknowledge that the nigga hasn't dropped a project in six years and has gone through a lot in his personal life (Marriage, having a kid, separation and divorce, a universally panned album) since then. The album is all about his personal development, transformation, and rediscovering himself in that time. It's safe to assume that he's going to be self-conscious about himself and music because his whole life was put out on display on social media and people shat on him.

Again, I don't care much for the album but to call what he discusses on this project "shallow" is pretty f***in insane lol especially when this f*** nigga Alphonse busts it wide open for the run of the mill dime a dozen d*** addict rapper with the same tired triplet punch-in flow. None of that is shallow to him, but apparently songs about getting knocked down and facing humiliation after your marriage failed in the public eye and having to bounce back from that is shallow...

Again when it comes to these P4K scores I don't even necessarily disagree with them in some cases, but their explanations behind their scores are always so f***in dogshit lol

They need new reviewers tbh

Alphonse is terrible, he fundamentally doesn't understand a lot of the s*** he reviews. I think they keep him specifically cus his s***ty writing & takes generate clicks and attention, he's really the only one doing that for p4k now